Noodle Pudding

All 93 rated mentions, most helpful first

in:Favorite “value” restaurant10 pts
“$15 bottles of house wine, and fresh, handmade pasta. Spend $40ish/person and you'll leave quite satisfied.”
H2
in:Lower Manhattan ‘neighbourhood’ feel restaurants 8 pts
“Put Noodle pudding (real good Italian, no reservations, cash only) in Brooklyn Heights on your list.”
H2
in:What's the best thing you've eaten in the past week?7 pts
“Chicken Milanese at Noodle Pudding.”
H2
postWhat are some decent restaurants with CHEAP house wine?5 pts
“My favorite example is Noodle Pudding with $5 house pours of montepulciano.”
H2
in:Does any restaurant serve Trippa alla Romana in Little Italy?3 pts
“noodle pudding does good trippa”
H2
in:Seasonal Ramp Dishes3 pts
“They do s great dish with spaghetti, bread crumbs and ramps.”
H2
in:Best Affordable Italian Restaurant NYC3 pts
replying to u/Konflictcam: Noodle Pudding in Brooklyn Heights is a great, old school red sauce Italian spot. If you’re down for an adventure, Arthur Ave. in the Bronx has a number of places that are exactly what you’re looking for.
“Second Noodle Pudding. Great menu with excellent daily specials. Good service. Reasonable prices.”
H2
in:Bamontes, Al Di La or somewhere else?2 pts
replying to u/BigOlSandwichBoy: i'm not saying this to be snotty because so many people have had such good things to say about Terre that it must have been wholly non-representative, and I may in fact give it another chance, but Terre holds the distinction of "worst meal I've had in NYC so far". Everything was gummy, underseasoned, weird af, the service almost bordered on hostile and a bunch of tables were dirty.
“The inside feels like a classic neighborhood Italian spot, charming but not cheesy, and the food is actually really good”
H2
in:Where to eat soft shell crab in Manhattan 2 pts
replying to u/Jog212: Noodle Pudding in Brooklyn Heights. It is just over the Bridge. Its stop in Bklyn on 2,3,A,anc C trains. They will have them Francese style. They are not on the menu but will be a special frequently. It's a great Italian restaurant with fresh seafood from Montauk. It is cash only FYI!
“i’ve had these and they are excellent !”
H2
in:Where to eat soft shell crab in Manhattan 2 pts
replying to u/Illustrious_Luck_948: i’ve had these and they are excellent !
“I just had them 2 weeks ago. SO FRESH! Tasty and delish!”
H2
in:Any recs for a spot for Sunday Gravy?1 pts
replying to u/mcletterrip: Noodle Pudding
“Noodle Pudding Sunday Gravy is amazing. Great vibe on a Sunday evening too.”
H2
in:Where to eat soft shell crab in Manhattan 1 pts
“It's a great Italian restaurant with fresh seafood from Montauk.”
H2
in:Looking for a great Italian spot in NYC that’s not IMPOSSIBLE to get into1 pts
replying to u/rickymagee: My favorite old school red checker table cloth Italian is Noodle Pudding in Brooklyn Heights. They don't take reservations. I've been there a dozens times and never been disappointed. Their bucatini is always amazing.
“While I've found it's good enough, it hasn't delivered anything interesting, or kept up over the overall improvement of the scene over few times I've gone back over the last ten years.”
H2
in:Birthday dinner for my best friend1 pts
“noodle pudding in Brooklyn heights is FANTASTIC. Traditional Italian with a lean fresh caught seafood.”
H2
in:What was your worst dining experience in NYC?1 pts
“Food was beyond sloppy. Pasta sauce was watery.”
H2
in:Birthday dinner recommendations in May - Brooklyn1 pts
“Henry’s End and Noodle Pudding for oldschool vibes.”
H2
in:NYC Traditional Italian Recommendations1 pts
“If you want real old school new york vibes go to Noodle Pudding”
H2
in:What are some good Italian restaurants to take 7 midwestern dudes (all in their 60s) who have never been to NYC?-1 pts
“Superb vibe, food, and service.”
H2
in:Birthday Restaurant Rec in Brooklyn-2 pts
“Even Noodle pudding but that’s not the vibe”
H2
in:What's your "go-to" casual neighborhood spot?39 pts
“Noodle Pudding”
H1
in:Cash only restaurants32 pts
“We happily eat at Noodle Pudding regularly! Cash only and no reservations.”
H1
in:Best Affordable Italian Restaurant NYC31 pts
“Noodle Pudding in Brooklyn Heights is a great, old school red sauce Italian spot.”
H1
in:Best unpretentious, classic Italians (pasta or pizza)15 pts
“Unpretentious Italian: Forma Pasta Factory, noodle pudding, Cafe spaghetti”
H1
in:What’s an absolute gem of a place you don’t hear talked about very much in the city? 14 pts
“Noodle Pudding in Brooklyn Heights”
H1
in:What are your three favorite bars and restaurants?11 pts
“Restaurants: Noodle Pudding, Vatan, Krupa Grocery”
H1
in:Best pasta in Brooklyn?11 pts
“Noodle Pudding,”
H1
in:These are the next 7 places I plan to eat in NYC. Feel free to add 3 more based on what you can see.10 pts
“Noodle pudding”
H1
in:I am having a huge craving for fried calamari. What are some standout places to get it, like either personal favorites, cheap but somehow still good quality, more-massive-than-average portion sizes, or ones that are served different than with the typical tomato sauce or aioli?10 pts
“NY Noodletown, Noodle Pudding, Randazzo’s”
H1
in:Best Italian Restaurants (with great wine list!) in Brooklyn9 pts
“Noodle Pudding in Brooklyn heights, pretty close to dumbo.”
H1
in:Best birthday dinner restaurants near the Brooklyn Bridge? (either side!)9 pts
“They only take reservations for larger parties but it’s a great birthday spot!”
H1
in:Looking for a great Italian spot in NYC that’s not IMPOSSIBLE to get into9 pts
“My favorite old school red checker table cloth Italian is Noodle Pudding in Brooklyn Heights.”
H1
in:Foods that are actually not overhyped in NYC8 pts
“Lesser known perhaps, (you stumble across them and hope not too many others do) dedicated, small independent businesses: Agis, noodle pudding…”
H1
in:Your top Italian place under $50/person, give me the reccomendations!8 pts
“Noodle Pudding.”
H1
in:Weekend in Brooklyn7 pts
“Noodle Pudding might be a better pasta spot than Lilia for your needs if you’re unsure about the hype for Lilia.”
H1
in:What’s your favorite NYC restaurant?7 pts
“Noodle Pudding is amazing Italian food.”
H1
in:Best Italian Restaurants (with great wine list!) in Brooklyn6 pts
“Closer to Dumbo you have Felice and the aforementioned Noodle Pudding.”
H1
in:What's your "go-to" casual neighborhood spot?5 pts
replying to u/PresentBasic3279: I only recently heard of Noodle Pudding and that it's great! It's on my list. The name always gets me, I think it's some Taiwanese restaurant haha.
“Noodle Pudding is my favorite Italian”
H1
in:Restaurant with Table RIGHT next to Big Open Window or Doorway?5 pts
“Noodle Pudding. It's Italian. Very good.”
H1
in:Where to get dinner near St. Ann’s Warehouse in Brooklyn5 pts
“Noodle Pudding.”
H1
in:Where to get dinner near St. Ann’s Warehouse in Brooklyn5 pts
“Noodle Pudding in Brooklyn Heights.”
H1
in:Brooklyn Bridge Dinner3 pts
“Noodle Pudding”
H1
in:Not too heavy pasta/carb-loading recommendations?3 pts
“Noodle Pudding in Brooklyn heights, cash only”
H1
in:Where to go for Lasagna?3 pts
“Noodle Pudding Brooklyn Heights”
H1
in:Looking for a great Italian spot in NYC that’s not IMPOSSIBLE to get into3 pts
replying to u/rickymagee: My favorite old school red checker table cloth Italian is Noodle Pudding in Brooklyn Heights. They don't take reservations. I've been there a dozens times and never been disappointed. Their bucatini is always amazing.
“Have also been here and the food was fantastic.”
H1
in:Recommendations near NYC ferry3 pts
“Noodle Pudding in Brooklyn Heights.”
H1
in:Dinner suggestions Cobble Hill-ish area3 pts
“Noodle Pudding”
H1
in:Dinner suggestions Cobble Hill-ish area3 pts
“Cash only, but outstanding.”
H1
in:Italian restaurant for a tourist2 pts
“Trust me it's the best.”
H1
in:Eating Alone and Wanting Variety2 pts
“I’d suggest eating a meal at Noodle Pudding”
H1
in:Best Italian Restaurants (with great wine list!) in Brooklyn2 pts
replying to u/smithstreeter: Frankies 457
“Also, second all the reccos for Al Di La and Noodle Pudding on the thread.”
H1