“Even for dinner, it's the biggest scam ever - $9 bread, $19 for two boiled eggs and mayonnaise, duck main course more expensive than Daniel a la carte.”
H3
All 84 rated mentions, most helpful first
“Even for dinner, it's the biggest scam ever - $9 bread, $19 for two boiled eggs and mayonnaise, duck main course more expensive than Daniel a la carte.”
H3
“I'm so disappointed by Libertine. It was _really_ good the first one or two months or so of opening when they seemed heads down on all the dishes coming out of the kitchen”
H3
“Supper disappointed given the price point. Left hungry”
H2
“Mid food, garbage service. Nice wine list though.”
H2
“I think this is one of the worst restaurant sin the west village. it shouldn’t cost +$65 for a half roast chicken with its foot still attached. It was so scary”
H2
“Oof I was so underwhelmed. The prices are EGREGIOUS and the vibe is not any better than other stylish French bistros in the city.”
H2
“Limited and overpriced menu”
H2
“Dinner is even more disappointing since it costs twice as much.”
H2
“Libertine, which is kind of the same scam...bad, pricey food with no good service”
H2
“Five pictures and the only seasoning I see is chopped green onions and a dash of sea salt. Blah”
H2
“I think this is perhaps the most overrated restaurant in nyc”
H2
“I disagree. The tartare is very accomplished.”
H2
“Overpriced and really meh for the cost.”
H2
“Libertine. Underrated, imo”
H2
“I didn’t think anything I had was *bad* here, but it’s nothing creative and hoo-boy the prices are astronomical for what they’re serving.”
H2
“Food was good but not worth the hype at all”
H2
“Libertines duck two ways”
H2
“The scallop starter at Libertine is very good.”
H2
“You know it’s artisanal when they poke a hole in your potatoes”
H2
“I went there based on Pete Wells reco and was wildly underwhelmed. Have had way better steak tartare at far less expensive places.”
H2
“Libertine Duck deux façons has entered the chat”
H2
“Criminally so. The bread and butter plate was worth the price of admission.”
H2
“The duck was indeed a fail.”
H2
“I ate here with a couple of friends and really enjoyed the meal. Mind you I dropped 6 bills for dinner. Thought it was excellent though.”
H2
“did like the trout tho”
H2
“i reallt enjoyed my meal at libertine both times i went, but yeah, ther service and the space werent the best. fortunately for them, i only care about the food quality and will be back lol”
H2
“Some mid priced French restaurants to try might be: JoJos, Libertine, Balthazar, Le Crocodile”
H2
“It’s one of the best I’ve ever had, including in France”
H2
“Had the one at Libertine recently. It was excellent.”
H2
“Libertine has pretty outstanding food and the vibe is way less kitsch than other French bistros”
H2
“Libertine is just amazing!”
H1
“The time i was there last week, it was quite bad”
H1
““Amazing” 😂”
H1
“Fiaschiterria Pistoia, Sakagura, Eyval, Raouls, Libertine, LaRina, Sofreh, Vinegar Hill House, chez ma tante.”
H1
“This place is so WACK son”
H1
“Minetta tavern. Libertine (closing. Open until may 6th) I think.”
H1
“That’s not appetizing at all”
H1
“Libertine was super hyped by the press but turned out to be worse than the already existing options.”
H1
“Also maybe libertine or ernestos.”
H1
“Libertine is newer but has a great French bistro feel.”
H1
“Libertine”
H1
“Looks like someone took a dump in the first Pic”
H1
“libertine if you can get in”
H1
“Yup - if you want French, go to Le Veau D’Or…or Chez Fifi, Ha’s Snack Bar, L’Abeille, Maison Passerelle, Crevette, Zimmi’s, Libertine, Chateau Royale, etc…”
H1
“Libertine in the west village has this, but it feels less formal than Les Halles did.”
H1
“I’m just pasting here from my notes app of favorite restaurants.”
H1
“lol no it’s nowhere near the most satisfying meal in the city.”
H1
“Ops, Cervo’s, Corner Bar, Libertine (I know), Tolo”
H1
“I thought the dinner was really good but I admit that someone else paid.”
H1
“The way I wanted to love Libertine and then absolutely hated it...”
H1