Anthony & Son Panini Shoppe

All 113 rated mentions, most helpful first

in:Best chicken parm sandwich with a thin cutlet (not Defonte's)2 pts
replying to u/donut_butt: Anthony and Sons in WB has thin cutlets, though they’ll stack them on a sandwich. There’s also Emily’s Pork Store down the street, but the breading browning is a little more consistent at Anthony and son’s Fair warning: people on this sub don’t like Anthony and Sons because the price has gone up and it’s a popular place, but having lived in Williamsburg 13 years, I think it’s the best option open in the neighborhood today. (RIP Lorimer Market)
“I have tried this place a few times and every time it’s been disappointing. Specifically the hot sandwiches come out too wet, the bread is too soft and disintegrates and the cutlets don’t stay crisp IME.”
H3
in:Best Sandwich in NYC124 pts
“any sandwich at Anthony & Sons is always a treat”
H2
in:Best sandwich in New York102 pts
“the anthony & daughter from anthony & son in williamsburg”
H2
in:Best place for cheap large portions?41 pts
“Italian sandwich shops like Anthony & Son Panini Shoppe”
H2
in:What's the best thing you've eaten in the past week?26 pts
“Cheesesteak from Federoffs or FDNY from Anthony and Sons Both havent had in a while and was very excited to have again.”
H2
in:Best chicken parm sub in NYC?25 pts
“Anthony & Sons. But I get the FDNY (vodka chicken parm)”
H2
in:Healthy and filling fast casual options?25 pts
“Anthony and Son's best sub is grilled chicken + fresh mozz + broccoli rabe and it is enormous, we split it among two people”
H2
in:Best Sandwich in NYC17 pts
replying to u/Kcody949: Hard to top Katz when you really crave it — but any sandwich at Anthony & Sons is always a treat
“The Anthony & Sons hype train never made any sense to me. The prices have nearly doubled in 3 years, the ingredients are mid-tier, and they just don’t taste as good as so many other establishments.”
H2
in:Last 3 Months in NY; Send your best recs14 pts
“Anthony & Son - honestly any sandwich”
H2
in:Favorite eats around east side of williamsburg?13 pts
“Overrated from other suggestions : Bonnies and Anthony and Sons”
H2
in:Best Sandwich in NYC12 pts
“Godmother from Anthony & Son”
H2
postLooking for a great sandwich in Brooklyn.9 pts
“Both was good but a little disappointing. The main ingredients Eggplant and Chicken seemed to lack flavor in both . Great bread cheese and sauce on both.”
H2
in:Probably a zero chance of anyone knowing this9 pts
replying to u/Infinite_Carpenter: Sal Kris and Charlie’s or Compton’s. Farmer in the Deli might be what you want too. Mission Social is overrated.
“but prefer Anthony & Son for an Italian sub”
H2
in:Some eats/drinks from my first time visit.9 pts
“the sandwich from Anthony and Son was amazing”
H2
in:Best chicken parm sandwich with a thin cutlet (not Defonte's)7 pts
replying to u/donut_butt: Anthony and Sons in WB has thin cutlets, though they’ll stack them on a sandwich. There’s also Emily’s Pork Store down the street, but the breading browning is a little more consistent at Anthony and son’s Fair warning: people on this sub don’t like Anthony and Sons because the price has gone up and it’s a popular place, but having lived in Williamsburg 13 years, I think it’s the best option open in the neighborhood today. (RIP Lorimer Market)
“I love A&S Vodka Sauce. The FDNY is my favorite.”
H2
in:Favorite fried eggplant sandwiches that aren't eggplant parm?6 pts
“Anthony and Son eggplant special is the star of the menu”
H2
in:Best Italian Heros?5 pts
“The FDNY hero (chicken parm with vodka sauce) at Anthony & Son in Williamsburg is the best version I've had.”
H2
in:Williamsburg and Greenpoint, Dining Solo, Eat Everything. Recommendations please!5 pts
“Anthony and sons (sandwiches)”
H2
in:Recs in east Williamsburg-ish?4 pts
“Anthony & Son Panini Shoppe for sandwiches”
H2
in:Best chicken parm sub in NYC?4 pts
replying to u/DC25NYC: Anthony & Sons. But I get the FDNY (vodka chicken parm)
“Came here to say this + get a side of pesto to dip 🤤”
H2
in:Best Sandwich in NYC3 pts
“Anthony and Sons (FDNY)”
H2
in:If you had to spend one full day eating your way through NYC, what would your breakfast, lunch, afternoon coffee/snack, and dinner be?3 pts
“Lunch: The Godmother at Anthony & Son’s”
H2
in:Casa Cugine Sandwiches3 pts
replying to u/loamy4118: ahhh actually amazing callout, i LOVE emilys pork store and it tops this for sure. i also think emilys is levels above anthony and sons (*specifically for italian sandwiches) so in my humble opinion theyre both fighting for second place
“Godfather from Anthony’s is just as good if not better than the Italian from Emily’s.”
H2
in:Probably a zero chance of anyone knowing this2 pts
replying to u/pumper911: Mission Social has like 1 or 2 really good sandwiches but even those aren’t close to the best in the city. Agree about Compton’s. Really like Sal, Kris, and Charlie’s but prefer Anthony & Son for an Italian sub
“I prefer Anthony & Sons for their hot heroes”
H2
in:Is Anthony and Sons in Williamsburg actually good?2 pts
“Yes. Chicken parm is among the best and the one with the vodka sauce is also awesome.”
H2
in:Looking for the best rainbow cookies. Where are your favorite rainbow cookies in the city and what have you compared them to so far?2 pts
“Anthony & Sons in Williamsburg also carry Circo’s rainbow cookies so you can get an awesome sandwich AND rainbow cookies at once.”
H2
in:What are your favorite restaurants in Williamsburg?2 pts
replying to u/pumper911: L’Industrie for pizza Fedoroff’s has an amazing cheesesteak Anthony & Son is one of my favorite sandwich shops in the city
“I second Anthony & Son, the sandwiches they have are crazy. Some solid wraps and fries too”
H2
in:Eggplant parm sandwich without the sauce?1 pts
“Try the eggplant special at Anthony and Sons”
H2
in:Favorite eats around east side of williamsburg?1 pts
“The Wife panini at Anthony and Sons”
H2
in:Best sausage egg and cheese spots in lower manhattan?1 pts
“Anthony and sons near me has some tasty sausage links on their egg sandwich”
H2
in:To go near Williamsburg1 pts
replying to u/pumper911: Fedoroffs is amazing. In Williamsburg, other favorite spots are L’Industrie and Best Pizza for pizza and Anthony and Son for sandwiches
“Hit Emily’s pork store instead of Anthony and sons for sandwich or pecoraro latteria”
H2
in:What are your favorite restaurants in Williamsburg?1 pts
“The godmother and their chopped cheese are my favorites but the FDNY is a lot of peoples top choice”
H2
in:Best Sandwich in NYC1 pts
“The pastrami”
H2
in:Best Sandwich in NYC1 pts
“The Mario Special is pretty good, but a little dry like someone else said.”
H2
in:Best sandwich in New York1 pts
“The soza from anthony and sons in williamsburg. So so good”
H2
in:Which meatball hero would you recommend?1 pts
“I had a disappointing one from Anthony & Son Panini Shoppe. Meatballs and sauce just lacked flavor”
H2
in:visiting on a weekday1 pts
“Sandwich: Ediths, Anthony and son panini, court street grocers, Emily’s pork store”
H2
in:Rate our food tour1 pts
“All of their sandwiches are great.”
H2
in:Anyone have any Chicken cutlet sandwich recs? Have been to Faicco’s for Italian1 pts
“Fdny at Anthony and sons”
H2
in:Favorite eats around east side of williamsburg?0 pts
“Anthony and sons is the best sandwich bodega you’ll ever have”
H2
in:Best Sandwich in NYC0 pts
“For me it’s the Anonthy & Son panini which is chicken cutlet, mozzarella, grilled eggplant, roasted peppers, and balsamic vinegar”
H2
in:visiting on a weekday0 pts
“Anthony & Sons in Williamsburg has some of the best Italian sandwiches in the city”
H2
in:Best Italian sandwich spot??-2 pts
replying to u/pumper911: Anthony & Son
“think can do a lot better than that in the city. even in that area, would take the italian combo at pecoraro latteria over cold cut combo at A&S. plus don't have to endure the wait & poor service.”
H2
in:Favorite eats around east side of williamsburg?135 pts
“Anthony and Sons”
H1
in:Casa Cugine Sandwiches43 pts
“They are fine sandwiches and it would do well if it weren't right by Anthony and sons and Emily's pork store which are both way better.”
H1
in:Flying down from Chicago? Whats great that I won’t get there!36 pts
“Get a hero (not a sub) at somewhere like Anthony & Son.”
H1
in:What are you guys favorite places in Brooklyn for big meaty sandwiches?36 pts
“Anthony and sons”
H1
in:What are some restaurants that definitely *don't* skimp on the portion sizes?33 pts
“some other deli/sandwich spots that have big portions for sharing: katz's deli, faicco's and anthony & son's (in williamsburg)”
H1
in:Chicken cutlet sandwich23 pts
“I don't really think any of these are necessarily *better* than what I'd get at the now-defunct pizzeria in my NJ hometown, but all are solid options.”
H1
in:To go near Williamsburg20 pts
“In Williamsburg, other favorite spots are L’Industrie and Best Pizza for pizza and Anthony and Son for sandwiches”
H1