“when they were back up and operational the quality had fallen considerably”
H3
All 63 rated mentions, most helpful first
“when they were back up and operational the quality had fallen considerably”
H3
“We ate it down at a picnic table by the ocean. It was fantastic.”
H3
“Places like totonno’s were what we spoke about when discussing great pizza.”
H2
“I think the pizza is as good as ever, even if there aren't quite as many toppings available as there have been in the past.”
H2
“Tottonno’s at this point can be hit or miss and I’ve heard it’s very pricey.”
H2
“Totonno's for pizza.”
H2
“Totonno's in Coney Island is still the best pizza in NYC”
H2
“One of my favorite pies in the city.”
H2
“Haven’t been there since they’ve been doing takeout, but the pizza has been good”
H2
“The oldest family run pizzeria is Totonno’s in Coney Island, pizza is good”
H2
“It’s a shame, I always recommended their pizza but I can’t say I’m surprised.”
H2
“the pizza was amazing and worth the trip from Queens”
H2
“The pizza is good”
H2
“this was by far my favorite pie.”
H2
“Can’t believe the best pizza in NYC hasnt been mentioned. Totonnos in Coney Island”
H2
“Totonno’s and L&B for the square”
H2
“Pizza should try Ny Pizza Suprema, Totonno’s (if they’re open), L&B Spumoni Gardens”
H2
“The white pie is the best”
H2
“Totonno's is open on weekends. One of the best pies in the city, imo.”
H2
“its overpriced and not good”
H2
“If you are in Brooklyn, you have to order from Totonnos. The same family has been making pizza for 100 years in the same spot.”
H2
“Some of the best I've ever had within that genre of pizza.”
H2
“Expensive for the size of what you get but I think it’s my favorite pizza in NYC. Go while you can!”
H2
“For Pizza I’d do something classic like Totonno’s in Coney Island”
H2
“the pie is still excellent and the banter/vibe is very amusing and enjoyable”
H2
H1
“Also, he gave Tottono's in Coney Island a mid review, and that's probably the best pizza I've ever eaten.”
H1
“I'd totally skip totonnos unless you want to go to it for its history. Not great pizza anymore”
H1
“It want $60 good pizza, just average sadly.”
H1
“So good!”
H1
“Yeah, the magic is still there”
H1
“Totonno’s is the pizzeria in Coney Island”
H1
“v tasty and eccentric”
H1
“it's good, I wouldn't necessarily make a trek out there for it specifically, but if you should find yourself in Coney Island and hungry, it's a solid experience.”
H1
“6. Totonno's”
H1
“Head towards Coney Island and both L&B and Totonnos”
H1
“Try something different: L&B or Totonno’s in Brooklyn.”
H1
“its a shell of its former self.”
H1
“Totonno's is the best pizza I've ever had, only been once though because of where it is”
H1
“it wasn’t the same when I went after they reopened (still fine, but not the same).”
H1
“delicious but apparently got much worse after covid according to reviews”
H1
“Had to scroll way too far to find my Totonno’s crew”
H1
“Totonnos, ocean view cafe, toné cafe, kashkar cafe”
H1
“Totonno's (when they're open....)”
H1
“Totonno’s FTW.”
H1
“Try Totonno’s”
H1
“Totonno's in Coney Island if open (to go only)”
H1
“Totonno’s.”
H1
“Faves are John's, Totonno's, Suprema and the original Patsy's in Harlem.”
H1
“Totonno's can be a mixed bag sometimes”
H1