“Their burgers are so flavorless. I don't know if they buy the lowest grade beef or something but it tastes like cardboard with oil in it.”
H3
All 116 rated mentions, most helpful first
“Their burgers are so flavorless. I don't know if they buy the lowest grade beef or something but it tastes like cardboard with oil in it.”
H3
“The meat wasn't beefy and toppings seemed flavorless. The shoestring fries were above average but seemed skimpy. I think they haven't improved with the better options popping up.”
H3
“Last time I went, both burgers we ordered were dripping wet and impossible to pick up. The bottom bun disintegrated”
H3
“Paul’s is terrible now and the service is even worse.”
H2
“Pains me to say, but it really isn't that great. It's like they steam all the flavor out of the thing when they use those covers.”
H2
“Been a few times. It’s cheap and large but I’ve always found it pretty underseasoned.”
H2
“Flavor is lacking but there’s something charming about just a mid burger with fresh hot fries (never salted right 🤣) lots of ketchup, and an ice cold beer in that classic environment”
H2
“I don’t recommend it. It’s just a boring burger.”
H2
“I’d rather go to Paul’s on 2nd off St. Marks and get a real burger.”
H2
“the burger was just okay”
H2
“Paul's on 2nd Ave is the best burger in the city, and it's pretty cheap, too, esp considering how much meat you get!”
H2
“I tried Paul's and it tasted like they forgot to season the meat. Am I missing something?”
H2
“Yeah they don’t season anything (including their fries) but I admittedly love Paul’s… very very basic burger but it reminds me backyard BBQ / family picnic nostalgia vibes, which I love”
H2
“Never thought this was that good of a burger.”
H2
“It’s like they don’t even have salt in the building. Bland af”
H2
“Paul's Da Burger Joint being the #2 burger is absolutely absurd”
H2
“They could win for best pickles at the table.”
H2
“Burgers are not my style but the pickles rock!”
H2
“I thought it was decent and large portion, but a little pricey.”
H2
“It's a mess and the bun is disintegrated by the time you are done, but it's my favorite burger in NYC.”
H2
“Damn good burgers though”
H2
“The opposite of dry.”
H2
“They don't know how to salt their burgers, that's why. If you want an unseasoned hunk of ground beef, more power to you.”
H2
“to me, no comparison. 7th street is a smash burger, which are not my favorite. I want a thick burger that is 75%+ MEEEAAAT.”
H2
“Burger taste like air to me. Atleast their huge. Amazing steak fries tho”
H2
“Paul's is such a dark horse, I love their burger and the bucket of pickles.”
H2
“Similar to Paul’s as in just a thick patty on a bun. Neither my favorite.”
H2
“when I went this year, I feel like they've fallen off tremendously. It could also be that current burgers are so much better and they are very much stuck in the past.”
H2
“I like Paul’s by St. Marks its a large patty and super cheap compared to everyone else.”
H2
“This can be an issue, they also have an option to sub in a kaiser roll for the flimsy bun.”
H2
“Great burgers, average price, and no line out the door like that one cheeseburger guy. They make them to order and I’ve always love them.”
H2
“One of the worst burgers I’ve ever had.”
H2
“One of the places I keep going back to is still Paul’s Da Burger Joint.”
H2
“I went there once and walked away very happy. I went a second time and got a burger that gave me the ick from almost TOO much burger. Unfortunate that it was somewhat hit or miss.”
H2
“the best old school big ass greasy spoon ass diner burger is Paul’s”
H2
“some of the best burgers I ever had were at Paul's near St. Mark's”
H2
“Paul’s da burger joint has some great burgers.”
H2
“Damn good burgers and shakes, cool place too”
H2
“For more classic burgers, Joe Junior or Paul's Da Burger Joint.”
H2
“this is my favorite spot for a big fat regular ole burger and steak fries.”
H2
“Can't imagine going anywhere else for a cheap burger in NYC unless out of necessity.”
H2
“If you don't order Paul's rare, you're doing it wrong. Honestly unless this place'll do it rare it's probably not breaking my top 5.”
H2
“Paul's Da Burger Joint is a better burger.”
H2
“I was just there service was good, and quality is great still”
H2
“Paul’s Da Burger Joint”
H1
“Corner Bistro, Burger Joint, Paul’s”
H1
“I’ll just say Paul’s Da Burger Joint again I guess.”
H1
“Paul's Da Burger Joint”
H1
“Paul’s da burger joint on 2nd ave”
H1
“it’s just okay”
H1