All 105 rated mentions, most helpful first
“Petee's Pie has to be hands down the best Apple Pie. I went during the pandemic almost every weekend to get one whole pie for comfort and devour this bad boy. I loved it and still do. It's flakey, buttery and the apple is just perfectly crunchy/soft combining it all together.”
H3
“Thanksgiving Pies from Librae, Petee's Pie, Four and Twenty Blackbirds”
H2
“Petee's pies has the best pies. I did a pretty extensive taste-test for my wedding and they were the winner.”
H2
“apple pie from petee’s pie!”
H2
“I’d go to the nearest Petee’s pie afterwards. It might not have a sit down ambiance but the pie is top notch.”
H2
“Petee’s pies are around $45 normally which is already steep for a pie, but probably worth it.”
H2
“I love taking people to Petee's, LES location. Takeaway pie slices and homemade ice cream, and if you ask they're cool about bringing a bottle of bubbles (or whatever) and posting up on their table with slices and bubbles.”
H2
“Petee's sour cherry pie is great!”
H2
“Petee's Pies for -- the pies (I like the cherry crumb and the various chess pies)”
H2
“Thanksgiving Pies from Librae, Petee's Pie, Four and Twenty Blackbirds”
H2
“Petees beats four & twenty, imho. Their fruit pies are fantastic but their chess pies are INSANE.”
H2
“Got their chocolate cream literally this afternoon. Can confirm”
H2
“I second this. Apple crumb or banana creme mmmmm”
H2
“The blueberry and coconut cream pie have me in a chokehold!”
H2
“I don't really like pie.. but I like Peetee's a lot. I love their chocolate chess pie 🤤”
H2
“I also like Petee's and Four and Twenty Blackbirds for their apple pie.”
H2
“I like the brown butter honey pecan and salty chocolate chess.”
H2
“The best pie in the city”
H2
“Thanksgiving Pies from Librae, Petee's Pie, Four and Twenty Blackbirds”
H2
“I still maintain Four and Twenty Blackbirds pie is better than Petees in every regard.”
H2
“Guava mascarpone pie from Petee’s pie company in LES”
H2
“Slice of salty chocolate chess and/or sour cherry from Petee’s Pie”
H2
“Pie: Petee's Pie”
H2
“Berry dream pie at Petee's Pie (first time I had it my mind was blown but when I went back last summer it was not nearly as amazing. hoping that was just an off day or something, need to go back and try again)”
H2
“I always get my pies from petees!”
H2
“Petees pie is always worth the commute.”
H2
“the amount of petees pie i’ve eaten over the years is embarrassing. it’s so good!!”
H2
“It was some damn good pie.”
H2
“2 (not pizza) pie places I love: Petee's (LES)”
H2
“Petee's Pies make good pies and their cheesecake is good too.”
H2
“The cherry pie is delicious”
H2
“The cherry crumble pie at petee’s is so perfect”
H2
“I don’t like pies at all. And I destroy Petee’s every time there’s one around”
H2
“The sour cherry crumb and the chocolate chess pies are soooo good.”
H2
“Petee’s Pie Company is great too for their chocolate cream pie :)”
H2
“Petees Pie. Chocolate Chess.”
H2
“also had cherry pie from Petee’s, wasn’t a healthy night but was still awesome”
H2
“Their key lime is good but really all their pies are good!”
H2
“Petees pie company is unmatched in Manhattan”
H2
“The Blueberry is my favorite, but they have other good ones as well.”
H2
“Pumpkin pie at Petee’s”
H2
“the salted caramel apple from Four and Twenty Blackbirds > the apple from Petee's.”
H2
“Some people like Peeteys but I hate how their fruit pies are cornstarch laden”
H2
“I agree that Petee’s Pies are amazing.”
H2
“Petee’s pie or magnolia’s banana pudding are both contenders.”
H2
“I dream about the maple whipped cream on top of the pecan pie. Insane.”
H2
“I love Petee's. I get their brown butter pecan pie a la mode”
H2
“Petee’s except go for the sweet potato pie instead”
H2
“Petee’s is your answer but also get a slice of lavish chocolate crème pie. Thank me later”
H2
“Never had a bad slice.”
H2