“7.5/10, we really enjoyed it. This was the personal pan size and was plenty.”
H2
All 114 rated mentions, most helpful first
“7.5/10, we really enjoyed it. This was the personal pan size and was plenty.”
H2
“Incredible pizza. Great service. Great price too.”
H2
“One of the best pizzas in NYC. Actually super good”
H2
“The pizza was pretty good. I liked it better than John's on Bleeker St because I don't like how John's have 0 crust.”
H2
“Most underrated but not really a secret - Angelos on 57th.”
H2
“Amazing pizza.”
H2
“Angelo’s coal oven pizza is down the street on 57th and has very good pizza. The Milanese is excellent too.”
H2
“If you can get a whole pie, Angelo’s on 57.”
H2
“Their chicken parm entree is also good!”
H2
“go to best pizza in BK or Angelo’s pizza for a nice sit down pizza”
H2
“Angelo’s Coal Oven Pizzeria is my fav. Their Margherita pizzas are damn good”
H2
“Angelo's coal fired pizza for lunch.”
H2
“Angelo’s is a solid choice for coal oven”
H2
“Take her for pizza at angelo's on 57th.”
H2
“Angelo’s for pizza”
H2
“Angelo’s pizza is the best”
H2
“I think it's better than almost all of the places mentioned in this thread”
H2
“I do admit they are *much* better if you have them in person in the restaurant as opposed to take-out.”
H2
“Angelos pizza is pretty good”
H2
“Seconding Angelo’s for pizza.”
H2
“Try Angelo’s Coal Oven Pizza on W. 57th if you want an amazing pie with no wait. One of the best pizzas in NYc and definitely underrated .”
H2
“Whole pie - Angelo’s on 57th.”
H2
“Underrated: Guiseppina's, Made In NY, Angelo's”
H2
“Angelos is great NYC pizza, and there's usually not a huge wait.”
H2
“Angelos is great NYC pizza, and there's usually not a huge wait.”
H2
“Angelos on 57th for pizza”
H2
“Angelo's pizza in the Ed Sullivan theater is pretty good.”
H2
“I had Angelo's on 57th over the weekend and it was truly outstanding. The sauce in particular was mind-blowningly tasty.”
H2
“The pizza is similar (as it should be), but just isn’t as good. The crust isn’t as crunchy.”
H2
“In midtown, would do Angelo’s for pizza.”
H2
“Then order pizza from Angelo's down the street. Really good coal fired pizza.”
H2
“Best trad pizza by pie - angelos/ John’s of Broadway”
H2
“Try Angelo’s Coal Oven Pizzeria on 57th street for some incredible sit down pizza with no wait”
H2
“I’ve been twice, one time it was fantastic, the other time very stale and the quality of toppings was meh”
H2
“Angelos pizza or patsys is a decent pizza spot”
H2
“Patsy's PIzzeria/Grimaldi's/Angelo's (midtown) is great for this or any sit-down coal/wood fire oven pizza place.”
H2
“Both have good brick or coal oven pizzas.”
H2
“The dough on that pizza looks dry and cardboardish”
H2
“Try Angelo's. No slices, but it's worth getting a small cheese pie by yourself. Especially drunk, lol.”
H2
“Pizza: slices at joes, slices at NY Pizza Suprema. or full pie at angelos”
H2
“It’s great, but the complete opposite of a slice IMO.”
H2
“Angelos coal oven pizza is really delicious they do amazing family style pizza and pasta dishes and good for groups. Service is also great.”
H2
“Been downhill since the second ave location closed but still. Fuck Angelo's.”
H2
“Overall, I highly recommend each restaurant.”
H1
“last day lunch at Angelos 8/10”
H1
“I like John’s, Rubirosa, L’Industrie, and Angelo’s on 57 better.”
H1
“Absolute sleeper of a spot”
H1
“Angelo's is as good as it gets”
H1
“I go to the Angelos on 57th often. LOVE it.”
H1
“Angelo's Pizza is touristy but quite yummy.”
H1