“7.5/10, we really enjoyed it. This was the personal pan size and was plenty.”
H2
8.2/10Italian
AI-generated summary
Order a whole , they don't do slices. People call the one of the best in the city and single out the sauce. There's usually no wait, which is rare for this good in midtown. Eat in if you can, a few people say it doesn't travel well.
“7.5/10, we really enjoyed it. This was the personal pan size and was plenty.”
H2
“Incredible pizza. Great service. Great price too.”
H2
“One of the best pizzas in NYC. Actually super good”
H2
“The pizza was pretty good. I liked it better than John's on Bleeker St because I don't like how John's have 0 crust.”
H2
“Most underrated but not really a secret - Angelos on 57th.”
H2
“Amazing pizza.”
H2
“Angelo’s coal oven pizza is down the street on 57th and has very good pizza. The Milanese is excellent too.”
H2
“If you can get a whole pie, Angelo’s on 57.”
H2
“Their chicken parm entree is also good!”
H2
“go to best pizza in BK or Angelo’s pizza for a nice sit down pizza”
H2
“Angelo’s Coal Oven Pizzeria is my fav. Their Margherita pizzas are damn good”
H2
“Angelo's coal fired pizza for lunch.”
H2