All 115 rated mentions, most helpful first
“they refused to engage with my boyfriend at the time due to him being black and they flat out refused a modification to my order which was to add chicken to a pasta dish. Then when I asked them if they'd recommend something else, they said no again.”
H3
“I ordered cacio e pepe at Serafina and basically just got a cold spaghetti brick with no seasoning or flavor and a shrivel of sauce.”
H3
“The Pizza at Serafina is legitimate.”
H2
“Serafina has entrees in the low $20s and is pretty good and popular, and has a lovely aesthetic.”
H2
“the bottom ten aren’t worth it in my opinion (especially looking at you Serafina 👀).”
H2
“In what world is any Serafina ever worth the time or money?”
H2
“even though I’m not a fan of them Serafina altogether, they have a salad with fried goat cheese balls that’s pretty good”
H2
“i love their cacio e pepe pasta.”
H2
“restaurants like Serafina, Tao, and Zuma wanna charge you for a room with your overpriced frozen lobster tail.”
H2
“The pizza is actually great, everything else went down the gutter”
H2
“I nannied for a little girl that loved Serafina! Midday is usually pretty chill and the food is not-quite-olive-garden-level americanized italian :)”
H2
“Had a late dinner at 38th & Madison and really, really liked it. Their Al Limone was freakin fantastic.”
H2
“Serafina is boring enough for a crowd. Bring enough napkins to remove the extra gloppy sauce on everything.”
H2
“I went there with a group of friends and ordered the lasagna, I really loved it, but maybe it was just that one dish”
H2
“I once went to this restaurant. The waiter got mad at me when a fly flew into my wine. Like got ghetto mad.”
H2
“Squid ink pasta at Serafina”
H2
“I went there and had a good experience in 2018, but I went with family last year and it was bland”
H2
“Also violently bland and just atrocious in flavor. Even the pizza was somehow ass. Never ever again.”
H2
“Serafina is a chain, but honestly I think it's fine for a first date - if memory serves they have good share plates for apps, which is always key for a happy hour drink situation.”
H2
“The pizza at Serafina is solid, and a good example of thin crust Roman style. The rest of the chain, and its Trump-Supporting owner, are pretty terrible though”
H2
“I’ve had consistently bad service at serafina…extremely slow and staff have mixed up my dishes multiple times. I feel pretty neutrally on the food”
H2
“Serafina is passable, but definitely not worth the price”
H2
“Reliable. Very good pasta.”
H2
“Reliable and not crazy priced.”
H2
“Serafina which is connected to the hotel has good pizza.”
H2
“They have a dish ....spaghetti with prosciutto and mushrooms......But I change it to rigatoni. Very Good!”
H2
“the cacio e pepe was so incredibly mid.”
H2
“Tell them you have no phone because you are lame like this restaurant.”
H2
“Serafina’s pizza is bomb and you’re wrong if you disagree 💅”
H2
“Both were very good. Especially the chicken. Also, good fries.”
H2
“Serafina on Madison for decent pizza.”
H2
“Serafina is good / good enough, and close and not expensive.”
H2
“Serafina is a good bet. Reasonably priced, reasonably nice, not trendy but good food.”
H2
“Serafina has a good burger and I like their espresso martini”
H2
“Serafina is excellent and reasonably priced for such a high end restaurant. I had sea bass to die for the other night at the 49th St.location.”
H2
“Serefina is worth a look”
H2
“Serafina or the Smith”
H1
“your first mistake was going to Serafina”
H1
“Serafina on the other hand is awful food.”
H1
“Serafina”
H1
“Serafina.”
H1
“truly terrible but def has this weird faux-upscale vibe that tourists love. bad food, high prices, lots of tourists? triple whammy”
H1
“This is the one!! The food is so bad”
H1
“Serafina is not great....There is better it lain food than that!”
H1
“So many childhood memories there. I love it.”
H1
“It’s just not good. At all.”
H1
“Serafina”
H1
“Serafina, Fig & Olive, Rosy O'Grady's, Capital Grille, Del Frisco's, Park Ave Tavern, The Modern, Del Frisco's.”
H1
“The OG Serafina on 79th. classic”
H1
“I did have a good experience dining alone i NY at Serafina on Broad St though!”
H1