“Most overrated: Janie’s. They are overly sweet, overly small for the price and the kicker is that they taste homemade/amateurish but in a way where I’m put off by paying $4 for a cookie.”
All 126 rated mentions, most helpful first
“Most overrated: Janie’s. They are overly sweet, overly small for the price and the kicker is that they taste homemade/amateurish but in a way where I’m put off by paying $4 for a cookie.”
“Janie’s is my favorite, specifically her guayaba and cream cheese pie crust cookies”
“We also tried Janie's pie crust cookie and enjoyed it.”
“Janie’s - pie crust cookies”
“Janies is excellent. Their pie cookies and half baked chocolate chip cookie are excellent”
“Pie crust cookies from Janie's life changing baked goods.”
“[Janie's Life Changing Baked Goods](https://maps.app.goo.gl/CgoZPhFYAVXBUtBF9) is 2 blocks from the museum and have these amazing pie crust cookies. Definitely worth trying.”
“Janie's have these delicious pie crust cookies that you can't really get anywhere else so it's unique and delicious.”
“Im obsessed with Janies but prefer the pie crust cookies - yum!”
“Janie’s forever, I love Janie’s!!!!! Perfect hit of salt with the sweet”
“They have pie crust cookies those are pretty awesome too”
“Their pie cookies are really good.”
“and a box of delicious pie crust cookies from Janie's life changing baked goods to bring home”
“Janie’s half baked chocolate chip cookies are what you’re looking for.”
“Her pie crust cookies are amazing!”
“I'd recommend bringing back bagels at a nearby good bagel place, The chocolate babka from Bread's bakery, Cookies from Levain's and Janies are always crowd pleasers.”
“They serve these unique and delicious pie crust cookies. Currently they're my favorite cookies in NYC.”
“Janie’s pie crust cookies”
“they have these delicious pie crust cookies. I'd definitely buy some and stash it for later”
“Go to Janie's life changing baked goods for some pie crust cookies”
“Best cookies I’ve ever had, and I don’t even really like sweets”
“Excluding maman my UWS list is Janie’s (the big Nutella one is just ridiculous, not the pie crust one), daily provisions, levain, then chip city in last by a good amount.”
“Cookies from Levain + Janie's.”
“I recommend Janie’s Life Changing Baked Goods. They have 3 or 4 locations and they’re famous for pie-crust cookies. They are very tasty.”
“Janie's life changing baked goods for their pie crust cookies.”
“Janie’s Life Changing Baked Goods for pie crust cookies”
“Janie's pie crust cookies”
“for their delicious pie crust cookies.”
“Janies life changing cookies. Because pie crust cookie”
“Janie's Life Changing Baked Goods have these really amazing pie crust cookies.”
“My favorite is the s’mores cookie with the big melted marshmallow on it”
“i love Janie's pie crust cookies”
“Absolutely delicious pie crust cookies, you can probably have your partner grab the cookies and munch on them while waiting for l'industrie.”
“Janie’s pie cookies”
“Pie crust cookies from Janie’s Life Changing Baked Goods”
“Janie’s Life Changing Baked Goods for pie cookies!”
“i really loved the smores and just the regular chocolate chip!”
“who have these amazing pie crust cookies.”
“Janie's has these pie crust cookies that are delicious and pretty unique.”
“seconding janie’s life changing baked goods. those pie crust cookies are something else”
“only way to get the cookies fresh in queens!”
“They make these amazing pie crust cookies that are absolutely delicious.”
“Janie’s cookies were incredible- strawberry rhubarb was definitely the right call”
“has an incredible rainbow cookie pie crust cookie for June. One of the best sweets I’ve had this month for sure.”
“The pie cookies from Janie’s Life Changing baked goods are delicious and stand up up travel if packed well.”
“The guava ones are absolutely superior. Even their chocolate chip cookie is pretty good though.”
“Those half-baked chocolate chip cookies were love at first bite! I love the pie crust cookies, too.”
“They make these excellent pie crust cookies and they're only like 2 blocks away.”
“these excellent pie crust cookies”
“Any and all cookies from Janie’s”