“it is fine ice cream, and they do have some fun flavors”
H3
All 118 rated mentions, most helpful first
“it is fine ice cream, and they do have some fun flavors”
H3
“The ideas tend to be interesting, but everything I've tried has either been actually bad (only 1 so far), or just safe.”
H3
“They actually move the line really quick, but the ice cream is just 'fine' (I think the sorbets are probably the best thing).”
H2
“Or ice cream from like salt and straw”
H2
“The honey lavender is so refreshing and delish! It's not too floral or too sweet.”
H2
“I really liked it when I went in LA and in Seattle. Not all of the flavors are super sweet, some are definitely though.”
H2
“similarly Salt and Straw has great sorbet (and meh ice cream) if you find yourself up there.”
H2
“i found their ice cream way too…. Salty lol”
H2
“I’ve been to one in San Diego and loved it. When they had a pop up this summer before they opened I went and tried the pistachio cannoli and it was SO GOOD.”
H2
“salt and straw’s ice cream is so cloying and heavy”
H2
“Try the lavender honey ice cream from Salt & Straw!”
H2
“salt & straw had an amazing limited edition cake batter ice cream over the weekend.”
H2
“Salt and straw is overpriced corporate ice cream you can get anywhere.”
H2
“Mmmm i like salt and straw but i also love sweet and salty flavors. My favorite is salted malted chocolate chip cookie dough.”
H2
“Yeah, like another commenter mentioned they do tend to be better at ideation than execution, but I appreciate that they try.”
H2
“usually I feel like their releases aren’t really worth the hype”
H2
“Their non dairy ice cream is the best”
H2
“Salt & Straw is dope. The olive oil and lavender flavors are pure millennial bliss.”
H2
“Salt and straw has a ricotta pistachio cannoli flavor that’s pretty good”
H2
“Overrated and don’t understand the hype”
H2
“their flavors are fun/exciting without being overwhelmingly sweet.”
H2
“I was really really impressed with the ice cream and customer service”
H2
“the wildest flavor of salt & straw”
H2
“Salt & straw is pretty stellar ice cream”
H2
“Ice cream: salt and straw”
H2
“Was not wowed by the pumpkin bread flavor at salt and straw.”
H2
“Overall it was just fine, but there are better flavors at salt and straw, and I assume better pumpkin scoops elsewhere.”
H2
“It's good but no better than equivalent existing options.”
H2
“Salt & Straw is dope. The olive oil and lavender flavors are pure millennial bliss”
H2
“It’s very good ice cream.”
H2
“The sea salt caramel is quite delicious.”
H2
“salt n straw is good but so are many gourmet ice cream places.”
H2
“One of my fave brands Salt & Straw just opened in the West Village. They do super fun flavors and also different themes/flavors each month. Worth checking out, I hope you like it!”
H2
“I would second Salt and Straw. I feel like they have a range of flavors across savory and sweet, and ranges of sweet options.”
H2
“my first two scoops from there were not sweet (the salted malted and the pistachio ricotta).”
H2
“I like their ice cream”
H2
“I tried it once, it was ok, definitely not worth the line wait.”
H2
“(Not bakeries) Ice cream/gelato: Cafe Panna, Salt & Straw, Anita La Mamma”
H2
“Salt & Straw ice cream esp. the Pistachio Ricotta and Coffee & Love Nuts flavors.”
H2
“I’ll admit that sometimes salt and straw has some inspired sounding flavors or ingredients but the execution just isn’t there. i truly don’t understand the hype. (and honestly find it kind of baffling that someone found a way to mess up ice cream)”
H2
“Skip salt and straw. There are much better ice cream places”
H2
“* too sweet for my taste but I know people love it”
H2
“Salt and Straw ice cream is my fav and always has a GF and vegan option”
H2
“I know it’s not cafe panna but I thought some of the salt and straw apple series flavors were quite good. The vanilla apple tart in particular”
H2
“Their ice cream is pants on head bad (weak ass flavors that just miss half of what they name it, same as panna)”
H2
“Ice cream, i’d recommend salt+straw for super unique flavors”
H2
“Depending on the month, Salt & Straw’s seasonal specials can also be really inventive.”
H1
“i’d skip Salt & Straw personally. I’ve only been a couple times but found it super mid. Even on days where it’s a promotion and it’s a free scoop or two, the ice cream just tasted sub par to me.”
H1
“I really liked it when I went in Portland!”
H1
“Salt & Straw (imo) is a huge skip. Not only is it not a NYC place, but their ice cream is extremely mid.”
H1