“vibes when it’s packed are a wee bit off as the servers def try to turn n burn the tables. felt weird having that treatment when we’ve ordered over $200 worth of stuff seems like they are overpriced for the service and quality (burger was meh)”
H3
All 133 rated mentions, most helpful first
“vibes when it’s packed are a wee bit off as the servers def try to turn n burn the tables. felt weird having that treatment when we’ve ordered over $200 worth of stuff seems like they are overpriced for the service and quality (burger was meh)”
H3
“ending at my personal favorite, Long Island Bar! LIB's deviled eggs are generous with the yolk, and the filling has a silky texture that to me makes it stand out.”
H3
“Mushy bottom bun and no crust on the patty. You want to see golden brown to bronze, not pale grey.”
H3
“The burger is solid, but the fried cheese curds are lowkey the best thing on the menu.”
H3
“There deviled eggs and LI Burger were standouts to me. Also, really liked their Long Island Gimlet drink. I would definitely go back.”
H2
“No you’re wrong it sucks don’t go there don’t get a cocktail and the chicken sandwich and sit in the window and people watch Atlantic that’s a terrible waste of time”
H2
“Cheese curds there are really good”
H2
“Long Island Bar with a martini 🍸”
H2
“Long Island Bar for burgers, cheese curds, and cocktails.”
H2
“Brooklyn, but two great spots opposite each other. Long Island Bar & Henry Public. Burger slightly better in the former - don’t skip the bacon pinwheel - martini slight better in the latter; but both great.”
H2
“As a neighborhood spot, the vibes are way off, even sitting at the bar. Go prepared to not stay long, like meeting for one drink before going elsewhere for dinner.”
H2
“Criminal to go there and not get the cheese curds. Great spot.”
H2
“The frozen Cosmo at long island bar is pretty special”
H2
“Long Island Bar does a killer piña colada.”
H2
“The last couple times I went it was loud, crowded, and I felt rushed (and the burger was just okay).”
H2
“It's Long Island Bar. Phil Ward's entire approach to the cocktail stems from his obsession with the martini and martini derivatives.”
H2
“Burger and a martini at Long Island Bar”
H2
“Long Island Bar has an amazing burger imo”
H2
“the cheese curds from Long Island Bar in Brooklyn are legit.”
H2
“damn do they make good drinks and a burger”
H2
“Long Island Bar is less cozy but is prob the class of the area.”
H2
“I adore LIB, but this combo with tax and 20% tip is $55 out the door.”
H2
“the cheese curds were as advertised and I remember being really impressed with the hamburger”
H2
“Long Island Bar is an absolute sleeper hit for top 5 burgers”
H2
“You can get an amazing burger at Long Island bar for like $23 I think and it comes with fries. Also dry aged.”
H2
“I have never seen someone upset with a double patty from LIB!”
H2
“Long Island Bar has a great burger and excellent cocktails.”
H2
“i recently had their burger and it tasted like stale rotten frozen burger. nowhere near good.”
H2
“Brindle Room, Long Island Bar, Superiority Burger for the fries alone.”
H2
“Wasn't impressed by either of those places for value v. price.”
H2
“sorry, but their burger is way overrated.”
H2
“I think it’s one of the best burgers in the city”
H2
“Cheese curds washed down with a gimlet at Long Island Bar”
H2
“Long Island Bar for sure…great atmosphere and a cool space too”
H2
“My bf and I have to go over to LIB every couple of weeks to get our burger and martini fix.”
H2
“It's a good burger, but way overpriced.”
H2
“I love getting their deviled eggs and the gem lettuce salad as my dinner.”
H2
“Such a warm staff too. A wonderful neighborhood location”
H2
“The vibes here can be immaculate or treacherous depending! It's such a coin flip”
H2
“I feel like their burger is very meh for the price”
H2
“I dislike the bun that they use on the burger, but the taste is good. Love the martinis”
H2
“Amazing drinks. Great burger.”
H2
“you'll dig Long Island Bar (great burger to eat with your rock-solid martini)”
H2
“It is a very good burger but it's expensive and I believe they charge extra for fries”
H2
“Long Island Bar - good burger better vibes.”
H2
“They have really good champagne”
H2
“I love Long Island Bar (first date with my wife there) but it’s not a chill local bar - it’s a trendy cocktail bar with a great burger.”
H2
“It’s both, IME. Lots of regulars and friendly bartenders.”
H2
“Amazing cheeseburger and fries that, I guess they are almost battered or something? I dunno but the burger and fries are amazing.”
H2
“They also have the best fries.”
H2