“I have had nothing but excellent food and experiences there.”
H3
All 137 rated mentions, most helpful first
“I have had nothing but excellent food and experiences there.”
H3
“In general I felt like the creativity on display did not actually make for cohesive, enjoyable dishes (apart from the cabbage).”
H3
“I hated Foul Witch when I went. Overpriced for genuinely untasty food.”
H2
“Foul Witch we quite liked at first - aside from the pastas, which we both found a bit anemic. Then on our second (no-pastas) visit it was like they were phoning everything in already.”
H2
“a few of my favorites are: the veal tortellini at foul witch”
H2
“It’s extremely good cooking but unfussy. I’d really strongly disagree that it’s overpriced because they’re using high quality ingredients.”
H2
“Honorable mention to Foul Witch, I’ve seen a lot of buzz on them but when I went the service was stiff, there was one standout dish (geoduck crudo, it was dope) and two that were decent but not memorable”
H2
“One of my biggest disappointments. Uninspired menu, portions were minuscule and the service, so disinterested.”
H2
“Agree on Foul Witch - tinyyyy portions and so overpriced.”
H2
“I’ve eaten there 5-6 times and totally loved every meal I’ve had, and several of those meals have been with out-of-town guests who still mention it to me.”
H2
“OK pasta with tiny portions and minor creativity but the place had great vibes”
H2
“The crab pasta at foul witch”
H2
“Foul Witch has an excellent bread situation. The mains get a little pricey but the pastas are great.”
H2
“Well done Italian from Roberta's staff. The space is very romantical”
H2
“Foul Witch has great bread and butter.”
H2
“Did not: foul witch. Major disappointment. Several dishes were bland, and the food was way more expensive than it had any right to be”
H2
“Dinner: veal agnolotti, focaccia and testa at Foul Witch”
H2
“foul witch was a tremendous disappointment from every angle - bad & expensive food, disinterested service, etc.”
H2
“Now that it’s settled I think consensus is mid and terrible service. Doesn’t play well with high price point”
H2
“I went six months ago and the service wasn’t great.”
H2
“100% agreed, I was expecting a LOT more food for the amount I paid. At least the free bread is good!”
H2
“Worth it.”
H2
“The veal tortellini with amaretto at Foul Witch”
H2
“Foul Witch - usually some variety of white beans with a salsa verde”
H2
“I’d recommend Foul Witch, it’s from the Roberta’s people with great natural wines list and more unique dishes (ie offal).”
H2
“This was great. The pici al peposo is also very good there. We really liked our experience.”
H2
“But the bread and butter at Foul Witch is 🔥”
H2
“Foul Witch gives delicious free bread and butter, even if you’re just having a glass of wine at the bar!”
H2
“The other two sneaky good pancakes for meright now are: Frenchette and Foul Witch”
H2
“Was not my favorite last time I went. The service was lacking. Food uninspired.”
H2
“I’ve been once, I liked it a lot and would happily go back.”
H2
“They had really wonderful food and I’m especially going to miss their sesame focaccia.”
H2
“fire & ice at foul witch”
H2
“For salty yet delicious pasta in a too-loud setting, hit up Foul Witch instead.”
H2
“The pickled mussel nigiri at Rosella, as well as the veal tortellini in brodo and the roasted goat shoulder at Foul Witch are up there as well.”
H2
“I enjoyed it quite a lot. Food was creative, and generally delicious. Service was solid.”
H2
“Foul Witch roast goat and mackerel were really good. Skip the whatever cake dessert it tasted like bad toast.”
H2
“Foul Witch has dope bread/butter service”
H2
“At Foul Witch the veal tortellini with amaretto is amazing but the real hit is going to be whatever pasta special they're doing that day.”
H2
“Oh yeah that tortellini”
H2
“would also recommend Foul Witch for more adventurous Italian. They use more unique ingredients than other places and execute well.”
H2
“I loved foul witch. I actually had the opposite experience. I had heard not great things and was pleasantly surprised. Food was great, service was incredible, vibe was playful.”
H2
“I rarely talk shit about restaurants, but I fucking hate that place. The food is mediocre, the space is cramped, the prices are ridiculous, and the service is bad.”
H2
“foul witch was ok when i went - the tortellini soup lacked flavor and the portion sizes were laughable.”
H2
“Go to Claud or Foul Witch or The Odeon”
H1
“I think the food is one star level at each, but the service may not be there yet.”
H1
“Personally don't think Foul Witch belongs on that list, tbh. Felt like a bunch of other places do the same type of menu better.”
H1
“The food was also kinda “mid” as the kids say.”
H1
“Foul Witch SUCKS, but is so hyped.”
H1
“It was definitely the most unremarkable meal I had in 2024”
H1