“really nice! 8/10, I liked how salty the bagel was”
H2
All 144 rated mentions, most helpful first
“really nice! 8/10, I liked how salty the bagel was”
H2
“Now we're getting somewhere. Better sauce than Ess-a-bagel, maybe a touch on the salty side. Quality fresh mozz.”
H2
“My top sandwiches: S&P Sandwich - Tuna Melt S&P Sandwich - 50/50 Katz’s Deli - Pastrami on Rye 2nd Ave Deli - Pastrami on Rye Carmenta’s - Spicy Eggplant Sub Barney Greengrass - Smoked Sturgeon on a Bagel Bagel Pub - Egg & Cheese on a Plain Bagel”
H2
“Pick one up today and it did not disappoint! Egg everything might be my go to now.”
H2
“bagel pub is top tier. Best bagel in Brooklyn imo.”
H2
“Bagel pub has been a favorite for over 5 years. Never had their Manhattan location but the 3 in Brooklyn are amazing. Huge portions, fresh bagels. Bang for your buck.”
H2
“Bagel Pub has them! One glorious bagel to rule them all.”
H2
“Bagel pub is best (and makes the best breakfast sandwiches)”
H2
“Even the bagel pub place fresh bagels are between that those listed places”
H2
“Had a good one at Bagel Pub in park slope a little while back!”
H2
“Tal bagels and Bagel pub are good standards.”
H2
“Bagel pub. I scrape off enough for a second bagel.”
H2
“bagel pub isn't bad and not far from Tompkins.”
H2
“Bagel Pub is the best bagel in the area 100%”
H2
“bagel pub in midtown has excellent cream cheese flavors including sun dried tomato (i believe).”
H2
“BEC from bagel pub”
H2
“Bagel Pub and Sofia’s Bagels are the best option for classic bagel egg and cheese.”
H2
“It is a giant often undercooked bagel that's nothing compared to Bagel Hole. They are like the bad guys in *Good Burger*, but with bagels.”
H2
“Bagel pub has the perfect one”
H2
“Best egg bagel around. It’s so orange”
H2
“I recently had a fresh bagel from bagel pub and thought they were good.”
H2
“Love their egg everything bagel!”
H2
“Agree on the bagel, will have to try the cannoli candy bar. Also their lox is surprisingly good, like russ + daughter’s level”
H2
“Love the Bagel Pub love. Personally my favorite bagel”
H2
“I think Bagel Pub deserves it for the bagel alone.”
H2
“Sure the place is fine, but their bagels aren't the standout.”
H2
“they have egg everything bagels that I think are delicious, might be worth a shot”
H2
“It has the best bagels I've ever had.”
H2
“I also love having tofu at Bagel Pub. They do it with all the classic flavors so I recommend the classic everything with lox, red onion, capers and scallion tofu 😋😋😋”
H2
“Lox fix #1 with the cucumber dill cream cheese has steered me safely through many a weekend morning.”
H2
“Bagel Pub makes excellent bagels”
H2
“The lox I usually get here will come from Bergen Bagels or Bagel Pub, and the nova lox is terrific.”
H2
“BEC at Bagel Pub or Old Brueklyn Bagel”
H2
“A good bagel isn't hard to find.. I like Brooklyn bagel co, bagel pub, leons..”
H2
“The Waldorf chicken salad from Bagel Pub (on a roasted egg everything bagel) takes me back home to Alabama.”
H2
“Egg everything not toasted, pastrami, egg, with extra white American cheese and chipotle mayo from there is 🤌”
H2
“Paid 12 dollars for a mid bacon egg and cheese when it used to be 6 dollars 2 years ago”
H2
“I like Bagel Pub a lot. Interest flavor cream cheese without getting too wild/weird. Good bagels too.”
H2
“Bagel Pub on 6th ave is really the only great bagel in the west village”
H2
“Bagel Pub is also not mid like OP stated. Amazing egg everything bagels!”
H2
“Bagel loving out of towners love it when I take them to Bagel Pub”
H2
“Such a mid ass bagel”
H2
“They lost me at Bagel pub… legit Omaha-quality bagels”
H2
“Bagel pub egg everything is the only right answer.”
H2
“Bagel Pub- everything, toasted, dill and cucumber cream cheese”
H2
“Bagel Pub is very good. And they have so many types of cream cheese if you’re into flavored cream cheese.”
H2
“Bagel pub is significantly better than Bergen.”
H2
“I got an everything bagel last time I was there and was not impressed.”
H2
“Bagel pub - don’t sleep on their subs”
H2
“I was actually astonished by all of the cream cheese flavors when I ordered last week. Insane!”
H2