“Terrible experience. They forgot my steak entirely and then brought it out with the wrong temp after my party had finished their meal.”
H3
All 127 rated mentions, most helpful first
“Terrible experience. They forgot my steak entirely and then brought it out with the wrong temp after my party had finished their meal.”
H3
“Found a long hair (that wasn’t mine) in the wedge salad and all they offered to do was replace the salad (after I was already 75% done with it and had basically lost my appetite). I’m not expecting a full comp, but SOMETHING to mitigate what was a disgusting revelation.”
H3
“Get a hanger streak (it has no business being as big as it is) with a veggie an fingerling potatoes for under $50 + a cocktail that keeps up in budget”
H2
“The ribeyes and filet were top notch, and the Old Fashioned was my favorite -- it was maybe the best steak I've had in the city.”
H2
“my favorite non-hyped steakhouse is Harry’s in FiDi.”
H2
“Harry's in Hanover Square and One if by Land Two if by Sea in the West Village both serve beef wellington.”
H2
“Great vibe, sort of "old school", legendary, and great for large groups. One of the best wine lists/cellar collections in the entire country as well.”
H2
“Harry's is my favorite! Get the polenta fries.”
H2
“Crown Shy (don’t sleep on the bar served patty melt), Harry’s (for the Wellington), Manhatta (for decent food but a wonderful view), Los Tacos No. 1, Keste Pizza are all decent picks in the area.”
H2
“the beef wellington at Harry’s in the financial district was fantastic.”
H2
“Harry's makes a great beef Wellington. Solid choice”
H2
“Below average steak. Bad sides. Bad cocktails. Unpleasant bartenders.”
H2
“Harry’s dry aged steaks are excellent, pretty much everything else is mediocre in my view.”
H2
“Underrated but so good and easy to get in”
H2
“Harry’s in FiDi, not as pricey is also good.”
H2
“underrated brunch too”
H2
“Great place, I still remember the last beef Wellington I ate there. It was so good, yummy food indeed.”
H2
“I second Harry’s down in FiDi. My youngest was into Ramsay’s shows for a while and wanted a Beef Wellington too so we went there. The dish itself is pretty simple but they did a great job, it’s a nice space, and the service was quite friendly.”
H2
“Delmonico’s or Harry’s for the steakhouse vibe that you can choose between based on budget”
H2
“Harry’s has a good one”
H2
“Highly recommend Harry’s in FiDi. Not got to the hype as everything mentioned here but nice ambiance and steak is consistently great for me.”
H2
“My vote is Harry’s .. hands down. Bone in ribeye is the correct answer”
H2
“Only been to Harrys and enjoyed their tomahawk”
H2
“the vibes are great”
H2
“Harry's has a good bone-in ribeye (and martini).”
H2
“Would rather go to Harrys and get their Tomahawk which was exceptional.”
H2
“Harrys is wildly underrated”
H2
“Great Beef Wellington.”
H2
“a damn good steak.”
H2
“Avoid Harry’s.. Quality’s disappeared and the service recieved was uncomfortably rude.”
H2
“The best steak I ever had.”
H2
“Harry’s is classic NyC style steak house with a thriving bar area and many beers on tap — including a great Guinness.”
H2
“Love Harry’s. Good food and good vibes.”
H2
“Second the rec for Harry's. Plus you can get beef Wellington there.”
H2
“Harry’s was phenomenal last week as their beef Wellington and 28 day dry aged ribeye was amazing. Just came back from NY with my wife and those were arguably our favorite 2 nights of food.”
H2
“I had the bone in ny strip at harrys and it was a disappointment tbh.”
H2
“I love Harry’s, everytime I go it’s always empty but I think their food is amazing and great prices for the portions size.”
H2
“delmonicos/harrys are good steak places”
H2
“Personally liked the steak better granted we got the tomahawk (special occasion) but it was exceptional i thought.”
H2
“My favorite is Harry's in FiDi. I'm a NY Strip kinda gal (nice balance between fat/flavor and texture), but they also do good steaks at both ends of the fat spectrum (filet or ribeye).”
H2
“I hate it :) Overpriced and inconsistent service”
H2
“Harrys in Fidi is fantastic and isn’t hard to get into”
H1
“Harry’s in fidi is pretty solid.”
H1
“Harry’s is my favorite!”
H1
“Harry’s Steakhouse”
H1
“Try Harry's (Hanover Square).”
H1
“Harry’s always holds a special place in my heart. Just really immaculate vibes. Great place to take summer associates when the firm is paying for it lol.”
H1
“Delmonico's, Blue Ribbon Sushi, Fraunces Tavern, Dead Rabbit, Adrienne's Pizza Bar, Harry's Steakhouse, Manhatta, Crown Shy.”
H1
“I second this. Went there last night, and half the table was wondering why Harry’s isn’t more talked about. Super solid but half empty on a Saturday night.”
H1
“Other options - Harry's, American Cut, Bowery Meat Company, Old Homestead.”
H1