“I personally didn't love it. I thought that the dough was nice, but the sauce was, iirc, very thick and acidic - texturally and concentration-wise closer to tomato paste, to me at least.”
H3
All 140 rated mentions, most helpful first
“I personally didn't love it. I thought that the dough was nice, but the sauce was, iirc, very thick and acidic - texturally and concentration-wise closer to tomato paste, to me at least.”
H3
“Love this place.”
H3
“I have a pizza oven at home and do my own dough, and am in awe of where they get to with their dough. Real skill there.”
H3
“sourdough pizza. Crusty. Chewy. Great sauce.”
H2
“Wheated is a place in Brooklyn with a unique thin crust style. The proprietor is extremely skilled with the dough making and happy to talk shop. Definitely recommend visiting.”
H2
“If you’re an anchovy fan like me, Wheated in Brooklyn does [a killer one](https://i.imgur.com/4nevV7X.jpeg).”
H2
“The owner Dave has all but perfected his sourdough recipe and pies and added new things to their menu that are incredible since the place opened. They've gotten a lot more press recently, and the quality hasn't dropped one bit.”
H2
“Wheated on Church Avenue in Brooklyn has amazing sourdough crust.”
H2
“Wheated in Prospect Park South. Come for the pizza, stay for the Caesar.”
H2
“underrated: wheated!!!”
H2
“100%. Wheated rules. Their New Haven style pie is excellent (so is everything else.)”
H2
“It's really great. I've never had a bad pie there.”
H2
“they are the best I’ve had in a long time.”
H2
“Wheated pizza”
H2
“In terms of pizza would direct you to Wheated, unique and exceptional.”
H2
“Be warned, this one has ruined most other ceasar salads for me”
H2
“The best pizza hands down.”
H2
“Ive double tapped wheated for breakfast and pizza before… no regrets”
H2
“Outstanding. It's so damn good. I normally like red sauce on my pizza, but this worked well together without it.”
H2
“They do it better than New Haven does I think lol. Sourdough crust and insane bar”
H2
“They do Sourdough bagels and one of the best biscuits I’ve had in a while.”
H2
“Yep! That burnt scallion cc with the lox too…”
H2
“there’s also bar seating too and they make great cocktails.”
H2
“i go all the time for biscuits and bagels, very happy”
H2
“Way underrated”
H2
“Wheated in Prospect Park South for amazing pizza”
H2
“Seriously, if you like whiskey, this bar can’t be beat for the level of pizza and selections”
H2
“They make a good cocktail. Pizza is excellent.”
H2
“such a good place and pizza.”
H2
“Wheated in Brooklyn makes a good Caesar.”
H2
“Wheated in Brooklyn, their New Haven white onion and potato, or their Gravesend”
H2
“Wheated for Pizza”
H2
“Wheated is a hidden gem. Pizza and breakfast are on another level there.”
H2
“Most underrated spot ever.”
H2
“Unfortunately the bigger pies just don’t hit quite right anymore.”
H2
“When I lived by them, I was there religiously. The first time I was there I was skeptical because they used an electric oven but don’t let that fool anyone. The pizza is excellent!”
H2
“Chocolate cake at Wheated is a new item on their menu and could be my favorite chocolate cake.”
H2
“Nah their Caesar has too much anchovy, and I like anchovy”
H2
“I took half the anchovies off and put on the pizza”
H2
“Yup, live right near it and go all the time. Great place if you love whiskey too”
H2
“It is so damn good. One of my favorite pizza places.”
H2
“It's also right next to my favorite pizza place, Wheated.”
H2
“we've found the pizza inconsistent at times, but still a good option considering the bar quality.”
H2
“I think it might be some of the pizza in the city.”
H2
“Suzis Roti parlor and wheated pizza”
H2
“Occasionally on special they’ll do a legit NH style that’s the closest I’ve had in NY”
H2
“My current favorite whole pie shop is wheated!”
H2
“Wheated is a great pizza spot in Flatbush as well. Great pizzas, great cocktails!”
H2
“Wylie should take a trip down to wheated and see how “boutique” pizza is done.”
H2
“Wheated makes great bagels.”
H2