“Benjamin's infinitely better. Same exact steak (since they are ex luger's employees) with much better atmosphere, service, and convenience (reservations & credit card acceptance).”
H3
All 143 rated mentions, most helpful first
“Benjamin's infinitely better. Same exact steak (since they are ex luger's employees) with much better atmosphere, service, and convenience (reservations & credit card acceptance).”
H3
“I’m also a huge fan of creamed spinach, and think De Stefano’s and Benjamin’s both do excellent versions.”
H2
“Both are better than Benjamin's. Benjamin's have a bad crab cake, their coleslaw doesn't work with the crab cake.”
H2
“For my money, Benjamin’s has the best quality steak in midtown.”
H2
“People sleep on Benjamin but their steaks and service are great.”
H2
“All of the above do excellent steaks in my opinion.”
H2
“There’s much better steak in the city (though I did find Keen’s surprisingly reasonable):”
H2
“The best steak I've had in NYC was from Benjamin Steakhouse. The porterhouse comes out sizzling and sliced on the bone.”
H2
“Benjamin's / Benjamin prime has quality steaks and good alcohol”
H2
“Benjamins for me (value for money)”
H2
“Bf just went to Benjamin's and said it was his favorite steak in a while”
H2
“Probably the best steak I’ve had at a restaurant”
H2
“My fave steakhouse is Benjamin. Very old school, Luger-esque but better. Every time I go to a new steakhouse I just wish I went to Benjamin instead.”
H2
“Benjamin’s if you really like dry aged flavor on porterhouse this is my favorite porterhouse in the city the dining room reads a bit institutional but food and service are always great.”
H2
“Big fan of Benjamin's steakhouse. Portion sizes are comparable to normal menu, just fewer options.”
H2
“Benjamin Steakhouse and The Sea Fire Grill are much better than The Smith.”
H2
“the steak didn’t have as much tastes as a Benjamin Steakhouse steak.”
H2
“Dry aged burger at Benjamin's on E41st Street. Get it rare.”
H2
“If it’s steak you’re after there’s quality meats, strip house, Benjamin’s and mastro’s.”
H2
“Benjamin’s was tasty but more expensive.”
H2
“Not in any order, but all are worth a try…”
H2
“For beef I actually prefer Benjamin’s and Wolfgang’s.”
H2
“with absolutely delicious food. Steak, soup, sides, seafood, raw bar,etc. you won’t go wrong!”
H2
“Benjamin's is a solid classic steakhouse. Also their baked clams are pretty good”
H2
“Wolfgang’s and Benjamin’s have similar style porterhouses to Peter Luger’s and I enjoy those, but the quality is not as good as my recommendations in my first comment.”
H2
“Classic steakhouse, good vibes, great food.”
H2
“Benjamin and Wolfgang’s are better and the service is worlds better.”
H2
“Benjamin. Get an on the bone porterhouse for 2.”
H2
“And no the non prime Benjamin’s is not one of the top level by a mile. Basically overpriced Charlie brown’s.”
H2
“Go to any Wolfgang's or Benjamin steakhouse -- each founded and run by longtime Luger alums who know exactly what made Luger great in the first place.”
H2
“Hawksmoor, Benjamin’s, Keen’s, Quality Meats are also all good options.”
H1
“these are good spots in the city I’ve been to: same as always, and people will nitpick my list but essentially Keens Porter House Wolfgang’s Benjamins Peter Luger La Tete D’Or The Grill Cote Hawksmoor”
H1
“Keen's, Benjamin, Gallagher's, Striphouse, Quality Meats, and Club A in that order.”
H1
“Benjamin Steakhouse”
H1
“Wolfgang’s and Benjamin’s are two of my favorites.”
H1
“Agree about the others though.”
H1
“Benjamin is pretty good too.”
H1
“Benjamins or Wolfgang’s”
H1
“would also add Benjamin to your list if it wasn’t there already.”
H1
“My preference is Benjamins.”
H1
“Also I like original Benjamin more than Benjamin Prime.”
H1
“Benjamin- 7/10, sides 6/10.”
H1
“benjamin steakhouse”
H1
“Basically, any number of nice steakhouses fit the bill: Delmonico's, Wolfgang's, Keen's, Benjamin, and their various competitors.”
H1
“4 Charles, quality meats, the grill, strip house, Benjamin’s.”
H1
“Wolfgang’s and Benjamin’s or also try the minetta tavern”
H1
“Strip House or Benjamin’s if that is what you’re looking for.”
H1
H1
“Benjamins steakhouse”
H1
“Seconding Benjamin’s.”
H1