“Visited more recently and the waiters were super bush-league, trying to upsell us on everything, asking if we wanted to get "fucked up" by ordering shots.”
H3
All 163 rated mentions, most helpful first
“Visited more recently and the waiters were super bush-league, trying to upsell us on everything, asking if we wanted to get "fucked up" by ordering shots.”
H3
“Old Homestead is reliable: solid menu, good bar. Is it the best steak, no. Is it reasonably priced, no. But it's very good steak and the location can't be beat.”
H2
“I think they have very nice cuts”
H2
“Old Homestead is ok. It’s got a vibe. Won’t rave about the steak.”
H2
“Old Homestead is overpriced and incredibly rude staff, wouldn’t recommend them to anyone”
H2
“3. Old Homestead — if someone in your party prefers lobster or prime rib”
H2
“I really didn't like it. The steak was fine though expensive.”
H2
“Old Homestead- porterhouse for 2.”
H2
“Old Homestead, Sparks, or Keen's would be good options that fit your vibe”
H2
“Sparks, Keen’s and the Old Homestead are good for expensive dinners.”
H2
“Enjoyed the ones at Old Homestead”
H2
“Old Homestead is worth trying if you’ve never been there.”
H2
“Prime Rib at Old Homestead.”
H2
“Old Homestead (less convenient, but best if someone in your group isn’t going to order steak)”
H2
“Best meal for me this year was Old Homestead’s Prime Rib. Ended up going a second time in one year bc of how much I enjoyed the whole experience.”
H2
“I happen to like Old homestead's actual steak”
H2
“Old Homestead if you want an old school vibe.”
H2
“The Old Homestead has pretty great cocktails, and it’s near where you’ll be.”
H2
“Go to Old Homestead Steakhouse, been a NYC staple since 1868.”
H2
“The staff are asshole and there are better and more affordable steakhouses in the city.”
H2
“Old Homestead was one of the best burgers I’ve had.”
H2
“Old homestead although havent had the rib eye there yet. Prime rib best in city”
H2
“I got the barrel cut filet mignon which was excellent so I can vouch for their general quality because their starters were excellent too.”
H2
“My jam is the lobster roll lunch at Old Homestead.”
H2
“Not in any order, but all are worth a try…”
H2
“As a steakhouse it’s on par with the others, but it has a more varied menu, including an excellent prime rib, lobster, and other main courses.”
H2
“Love their steaks”
H2
“This is my go to place for prime rib.”
H2
“I'd go to Old Homestead, I love their fillet mignon.”
H2
“Old Homestead in the Borgata is terrific in my opinion. The ribeye I had there was as good or better than any steak Ive had at a restaurant.”
H2
“Same with Old Homestead. Great staff too, every time I go to either.”
H2
“Love their French onion soup too, it’s roasted.”
H2
“If we’re talking best steak - Old Homestead.”
H2
“I think old homestead has the better steak”
H2
“I like it better than Keens, Old Homestead, destefanos, and Luger.”
H2
“just went Sunday and had a porterhouse which was excellent”
H2
“Take him to a steakhouse. Keens, old Homestead, something like that.”
H1
“Keen’s is my favorite or the Old Homestead”
H1
“Old homestead.”
H1
“And I still love Old Homestead.”
H1
“Old homestead is my regular go to.”
H1
“you're still better off at the Old Homestead if you care more about the food than the setting”
H1
“OH has been disappointing for me.”
H1
“Keen's, Smith & Wollensky, Club A, Sparks, or Old Homestead.”
H1
“Old Homestead is pretty good. I’ll start going back there now.”
H1
“Old Homestead”
H1
“Other options - Harry's, American Cut, Bowery Meat Company, Old Homestead.”
H1
“The old homesteads is suuuuuper roasted. It’s excellent best thing on menu”
H1
“Old Homestead, 14th St and 10th Ave., a 10 minute cab ride from the EV.”
H1
“I think Old Homestead would be perfect.”
H1