“worth the hype, sorry. The cereal milk soft serve is truly great, buttery, salty, sweet and creamy. With the cereal topping for more texture it becomes even better.”
H3
All 156 rated mentions, most helpful first
“worth the hype, sorry. The cereal milk soft serve is truly great, buttery, salty, sweet and creamy. With the cereal topping for more texture it becomes even better.”
H3
“most of the things they make are really mediocre now.”
H3
“Milk Bar's Birthday Cake is probably perfect. It is high sugar and butter, over the top in all the right ways.”
H3
“The Milk bar legitimately sucks ass. The cereal milk ice cream taste weird and does not taste like cereal milk to me. The former "crack pie" (they renamed it to something else) was basically a sugar pie lol. The cookies are meh”
H3
“Milk bar was good in its original form, but then they expanded and became sort of a factory premade and shipped to their many, many stores thing. It’s now very mediocre.”
H3
“Great actual deep cocoa flavor with some tang in a nice moist cake. Then, the cheesecake and frosting. It was a bit hard to know what was frosting and what was cheesecake when it was all together, but I didn't care. Super thick, rich, creamy, great cream cheese flavor. I quite enjoyed it.”
H3
“the Milk Bar Birthday Cake is the ultimate funfetti cake with artificial vanilla extract that screams childhood and it’s one of my favorite cakes of all time.”
H3
“It tastes just like lemon meringue, is very creamy, and isn't as overly sweet as most of their stuff.”
H3
“Milk Bar has been terrible for years. I keep ordering, including a big birthday cake for my daughter, in hopes of it just being a bad day, but nope. It's terrible. Very, very sweet and it all tastes very over-processed.”
H3
“Great actual deep cocoa flavor with some tang in a nice moist cake. Then, the cheesecake and frosting. It was a bit hard to know what was frosting and what was cheesecake when it was all together, but I didn't care. Super thick, rich, creamy, great cream cheese flavor. I quite enjoyed it.”
H3
“1/5 sorry these were not good, overly sweet, tasted very processed”
H2
“Milk bar is way too sweet”
H2
“6/10. This was fine, slightly too sweet for me,”
H2
“This was as bad as a run-of-the-mill nestle cookie if not worse.”
H2
“crack pie from Milk Bar is legit one of the tastiest treats I’ve ever had.”
H2
“If nothing is ever sweet enough for you, you’ll probably enjoy the funfetti cake from Milk Bar.”
H2
“Milk Bar Cereal Milk ice cream is great but close to 100% of everything else they sell is overhyped and cloyingly sweet.”
H2
“compost cookie was to die for”
H2
“I was so excited that milk bar brought back the Thanksgiving croissant but it’s basically just turkey now ( and dark meat only) such a bummer…”
H2
“No. Milk bar isn’t good anymore. They took on a bunch of money, overextended their brick and mortar business, pivoted to CPG, etc..”
H2
“Personally, hasn’t been the same since their big expansion from the small shop across momofuku.”
H2
“I actually still love the cereal milk soft serve. Like, I would totally go out of my way to get it.”
H2
“Milk Bar: their naked birthday cake is classic”
H2
“Never been a fan of milk bar- way too sweet for me”
H2
“but cereal milk ice cream… I think it’s a fair trade off.”
H2
“Depending on the month, some of Milk Bar's specials are good too (I really like the lemon one and carrot cake ones)”
H2
“but the current lemon meringue one was actually pretty good.”
H2
“milk bar does have a couple of great items, in particular the birthday cake truffles and the pie formally known as crack pie. Those are both worth getting while you’re in town”
H2
“Milk Bar birthday cake still hits”
H2
“Milk Bar's birthday cake is too sweet even though it's not always dry.”
H2
“Milk Bar birthday cake slices”
H2
“I’ve tried so many things from Milk Bar over the years and never got the hype. Cookies, cereal milk ice cream, crack pie. Not much flavor besides sweet.”
H2
“the milkbar thanksgiving croissant is awesome”
H2
“Got cereal milk soft serve recently, still hits.”
H2
“I recently tried Milk Bar's cereal milk soft serve at the location near the Ace in Manhattan. It was TERRIBLE and I was really sad.”
H2
“Milk Bar is basically inedible now compared to how it used to be. A friend got some while we were hanging out at a bar nearby a few weeks ago - even drunk I could only take one bite.”
H2
“Milkbar confetti or red velvet”
H2
“If you’re into the whole little Debbie’s/ Hostess Americana sort of deal definitely hit milk bar.”
H2
“Milk Bar has a celebration cake, and seasonal ones, that are great, high sugar, a bit over the top, but they really are tasty.”
H2
“The one at Billy’s is really nice, but I don’t know whether it’s cheaper than milk bar (it’s still pretty pricey) - it’s tastier though!”
H2
“Milk bar is not what you're looking for. It is over the top sweet and does not have a real vanilla punch.”
H2
“Downvoters have clearly never had the cereal milk soft serve”
H2
“Oldie: Milk Bar's cereal milk soft serve”
H2
“My gosh it really doesn’t get much better than that.”
H2
“Milk Bar cornflake ice cream”
H2
“I do love that cake. The birthday cake truffles are my jaaaam.”
H2
“It’s just cloyingly sweet now and feels like any other packaged sweets company on a grocery store shelf.”
H2
“Milk Bar changed drastically since it was bought. It’s a shadow of its former self.”
H2
“Milk Bar has great cakes.”
H2
“Milk Bar’s crack pie slice”
H2