Supper

All 201 rated mentions, most helpful first

in:Born and raised NYer’s, what is your overrated and underrated spot?45 pts
“Underrated: Supper”
H2
in:Best place to eat in Little Italy, Manhattan?43 pts
“Frank, Supper, or Daddies. All owned by Frank Prizinano. Great food, great family atmosphere.”
H2
in:Best Italian in the Village?26 pts
replying to u/QuesoDelDiablos: I’d definitely put supper over Via Carota. To be fair, Via Carota is very good. But Supper is better.
“Supper over Via Carota is insane. Think half the time I’ve order the Cacio e Pepe there the sauce has been broken.”
H2
in:East village19 pts
“For a great dinner where you need no reservations I’d recommend Supper which is a New York style Italian place.”
H2
in:One dish/restaurant you had to go back to the next day13 pts
“The Spaghetti Limone at Supper. Which fortunately is also available at their sister restaurants, because they know.”
H2
in:Good pasta in Manhattan that's a reasonable value?12 pts
“Supper. Great value and quality.”
H2
in:red sauce Italian10 pts
“had an amazing red sauce “this taste like my grandmas cooking” type meal”
H2
in:I’m in my legume era. Where are your favorite bean dishes in the city?10 pts
“The cannellini beans they serve with bread at Supper in the east village!”
H2
in:Who has your favorite bread and olive oil? Here's Via Carota's9 pts
“I really like the bread and that bean/olive oil dip at Supper.”
H2
in:Truffle Pasta Recommendations Please and more...7 pts
replying to u/spageddy_lee: Check if Supper still has truffles. They get fresh ones and shave them fresh on your pasta in front of you. It's late in the season (I think) but you might still be good .
“I had dinner at Supper and it was… not good. Like very avg Italian food with NYC prices. Would definitely not recommend especially if you’re looking for truffles”
H2
in:If you could only ever eat one pasta dish forever, in nyc, what would you choose? 7 pts
“Not that exciting but the spaghetti limone from supper”
H2
in:Best chicken parm in NY?7 pts
“My wife and I are big fans of Supper’s chicken parm”
H2
in:Best Pasta in NY?6 pts
“More casual, pasta al limone at supper”
H2
in:Italian Birthday Dinner - Manhattan6 pts
“Supper, Frank, Lil Frankies all a fun bday vibe”
H2
in:Best Bolognese in the city?6 pts
“Try Frank or Supper in the East Village. Get the Bolognese and then try everything else.”
H2
in:Most amazing vegetarian pastas?5 pts
“Spaghetti Al Limone @lil Frankie’s or supper”
H2
in:We got COVID and can't eat out - any last minute thanksgiving delivery in the LES?5 pts
“They’re doing a lovely delivery thanksgiving meal, it’s expensive tho. Ordered it earlier and it’s 100% worth it”
H2
in:kid-friendly non-touristy Italian recommendation5 pts
“Frank or supper in the East village do kid-friendly pastas in a chill atmosphere suitable for a 5 year old. Pasta is decent and they’re not touristy at all”
H2
postHelp me prepare a NYC dining bucket list!4 pts
“Some people clown me for this, but I think it's delish and cozy italian”
H2
in:Comfort dinner cozy restaurant for my friend who got broken up with4 pts
“Supper sounds perfect for this. Fantastic Italian food and the coziest vibe.”
H2
in:What restaurant does a plate so perfectly, you’ll just always eat there if you’re craving it?3 pts
“Personally hated the chicken parm at Supper.”
H2
in:What are some really good, somewhat under the radar restaurants in/around East village? 3 pts
“Supper is a great classic Italian spot. Cash only. The chicken parm is out of this world, and I love the lemon pasta.”
H2
in:Places open on Christmas night?3 pts
“It’s great Italian food and their staff are very well paid. I’d recommend Frank Restaurant and Supper!”
H2
in:red sauce Italian3 pts
replying to u/Oriellien: Supper in the east village. Very no frills, wandered into it one day, had an amazing red sauce “this taste like my grandmas cooking” type meal
“My favorite. Their chicken parm is so delicious.”
H2
in:Best Affordable Italian Restaurant NYC3 pts
replying to u/pinkpeachpie_: Frank/Supper/lil Frankie's - all in the east village
“Personally think these restaurants are mid, cool vibe tho”
H2
in:I’m in my legume era. Where are your favorite bean dishes in the city?3 pts
replying to u/FloopyCactus: The cannellini beans they serve with bread at Supper in the east village!
“the beans at supper are to die for”
H2
in:What restaurant does a plate so perfectly, you’ll just always eat there if you’re craving it?2 pts
replying to u/Bread_man10: Personally hated the chicken parm at Supper. My go to is John’s of 12th
“Haven’t had the parm there but loved the pasta”
H2
in:Must try eats in NYC/Unique American foods2 pts
“Priest Stranglers (pasta) and white beans bruschetta at Supper”
H2
in:Best chicken parmesean in NYC recommendation??????2 pts
replying to u/Garconavecunreve: Emilios ballato Rubirosa Supper Barano
“I’m sure it’s the best chicken parm I’ve ever had.”
H2
in:Late-night group dinner in NYC1 pts
replying to u/ciphermuses: Look into the restaurant group that runs Supper, Lil Frankie’s, Frank. I’ve done a bday with 20ish, not sure if they can accommodate 35-40, but they are open pretty late. Unfortunately it’s not in Hell’s Kitchen, but it’s tough to find places that will accommodate that late.
“Supper’s food is beyond mediocre. Except that wonderful horseradish Caesar.”
H2
in:BEST SALADS IN NYC1 pts
“Caesar at Supper. Everything else sucks.”
H2
in:Who has the best Caesar salad in the city?1 pts
“The black salt Caesar salad from Supper is worth an easy trip in from Brooklyn.”
H2
in:What restaurant does a plate so perfectly, you’ll just always eat there if you’re craving it?1 pts
“Limón Pasta at Supper”
H2
in:Italian restaurant for a tourist1 pts
replying to u/K04free: I’d try Little Frankie’s - cash only, walk-ins should be fine. You can also try Frank and Supper, same chef.
“I love the staff at Supper! The manager has been there for more than a decade and clearly loves creating memorable experiences for patrons.”
H2
in:What’s an NYC food opinion that will have you like this?1 pts
“The pasta at Supper is below average.”
H2
in:Date night Italian restaurant with great chicken parmesan and lasagna in Manhattan1 pts
“Supper had excellent chicken parm, and I think lasagna is available as a special during the week.”
H2
in:East Village dinner dat night recs1 pts
“Supper (same people as lil frankies) and lavagna were solid for pasta.”
H2
in:Italian Resto Suggestions - Engagement Dinner1 pts
“Maybe Supper if you’re down for more rustic vibes”
H2
in:Please judge my food itinerary for my trip!1 pts
“Supper (homey pasta)”
H2
in:What is the best chicken you’ve had in NYC?1 pts
“Frank/Supper do an incredible roast chicken w pan sauce”
H2
in:What is a great steak in NYC not at a steakhouse?1 pts
“They usually have a pretty good skirt option for brunch and usually some larger cut (ribeye or tbone) for dinner”
H2
in:Italian spot Il Buco, Noona Dora or Fiaschetteria Pistoia1 pts
“Supper (or any of Frank's restaurants) - reasonably priced and excellent food, very cozy, good service.”
H2
postWhat restaurant does a plate so perfectly, you’ll just always eat there if you’re craving it?236 pts
“There are a few times I try something, and I’m like “yep, no need to try this dish anywhere else in NYC again. This is perfect.””
H1
in:Best Italian in EV?37 pts
“Franks, lil Frankie’s, supper, il posto accanto (cavatelli) - all these are classics”
H1
in:Best Italian in the Village?28 pts
“Supper is my all time fave. It’s so cozy, the staff is lovely, and the food is BANGIN.”
H1
in:Which cozy Italian in East Village for my last dinner of my 3 nights stay27 pts
“I would do Frank/Supper.”
H1
in:Cash only restaurants17 pts
“Supper in Easy Village is what you’re looking for”
H1
in:Unpopular Opinion: We Cut Restaurants Way Too Much Slack16 pts
replying to u/Hopeful-Pollution-70: Who is Frank and from where did you get this 17% number from?
“I like his restaurants but man he's doing well out of them.”
H1
in:Best Pasta Limone?16 pts
“Supper”
H1
in:Best Italian in the Village?16 pts
replying to u/Party_Principle4993: It’s in the East Village but Supper is my all time fave. It’s so cozy, the staff is lovely, and the food is BANGIN. It feels very old school too and I’ve seen celebs there (not that that’s why you’d go but it’s kinda cool if you’re visiting NYC).
“supper is okay but nothing special.”
H1