Supper — FoodNYC

What Reddit says201

View all

in:Born and raised NYer’s, what is your overrated and underrated spot?45 pts
“Underrated: Supper”
H2
in:Best place to eat in Little Italy, Manhattan?43 pts
“Frank, Supper, or Daddies. All owned by Frank Prizinano. Great food, great family atmosphere.”
H2
in:Best Italian in the Village?26 pts
replying to u/QuesoDelDiablos: I’d definitely put supper over Via Carota. To be fair, Via Carota is very good. But Supper is better.
“Supper over Via Carota is insane. Think half the time I’ve order the Cacio e Pepe there the sauce has been broken.”
H2
in:East village19 pts
“For a great dinner where you need no reservations I’d recommend Supper which is a New York style Italian place.”
H2
in:One dish/restaurant you had to go back to the next day13 pts
“The Spaghetti Limone at Supper. Which fortunately is also available at their sister restaurants, because they know.”
H2
in:Good pasta in Manhattan that's a reasonable value?12 pts
“Supper. Great value and quality.”
H2
in:red sauce Italian10 pts
“had an amazing red sauce “this taste like my grandmas cooking” type meal”
H2
in:I’m in my legume era. Where are your favorite bean dishes in the city?10 pts
“The cannellini beans they serve with bread at Supper in the east village!”
H2
in:Who has your favorite bread and olive oil? Here's Via Carota's9 pts
“I really like the bread and that bean/olive oil dip at Supper.”
H2
in:Truffle Pasta Recommendations Please and more...7 pts
replying to u/spageddy_lee: Check if Supper still has truffles. They get fresh ones and shave them fresh on your pasta in front of you. It's late in the season (I think) but you might still be good .
“I had dinner at Supper and it was… not good. Like very avg Italian food with NYC prices. Would definitely not recommend especially if you’re looking for truffles”
H2
in:If you could only ever eat one pasta dish forever, in nyc, what would you choose? 7 pts
“Not that exciting but the spaghetti limone from supper”
H2
in:Best chicken parm in NY?7 pts
“My wife and I are big fans of Supper’s chicken parm”
H2

See all 201 mentions