“If you want the bland pizza doughs from years ago, Best Pizza has slices that fit the old profile to a T.”
H3
All 303 rated mentions, most helpful first
“If you want the bland pizza doughs from years ago, Best Pizza has slices that fit the old profile to a T.”
H3
“They are both great white slices but with fundamentally different approaches. Best is going for a ricotta led soft and tender white accented w the sweetness of caramelized onions.”
H3
“I think the crust on it kinda sucks, hella bland & no color, but the sauce is sweet and it’s blended very well with the cheese.”
H3
“I went there during my pizza crawl and found their crust to be super bland; zero char and pale AF. Their cheese & sauce was great, and it's nice to see a shop lean towards a sweeter sauce for their pizza, but that crust is so bad.”
H3
“The white slice from Best Pizza in Williamsburg (33 Havemeyer) is excellent! Sesame seed crust, ricotta, jammy onions. You gotta try it!”
H3
“The sauce/cheese blend is so good. I also like how they use a very sweet tomato sauce, very different from L’industrie and Fini, which leans tangy. I actually prefer tangy, but I love options. The only thing I can ding Best on is consistency. There were a couple of times where I had underbaked slices with a very gummy & pale crust.”
H3
“Best Pizza, the sesame seeds on it is so good. The crust taste like some sort of fried sesame bread.”
H3
“BEST PIZZA in Williamsburg is my go to, on Havemeyer. I think they use Roberta's sourdough if I'm not mistaken. No nonsense; sauce is slightly sweet and tangy (to my preference) and I do go with the garlic and red pepper.”
H3
“Slices from Best Pizza in Williamsburg which was really nice and light.”
H2
“White slice at Best Pizza”
H2
“that shit was bomb. So bomb in fact, that on the last day after eating two slices at L'industrie (and dessert, I had a pistachio tres leches), we went back to Best Pizza for another white slice”
H2
“Best pizza’s grandma is legit”
H2
“**3 Star:** Exceptional, worth a trip to another neighborhood.”
H2
“Los tacos and best pizza rule solid choices”
H2
“Best Pizza was so good, I’d definitely put it in my top 5, the grandma slice was also delicious.”
H2
“Ill get downvoted to hell but l’industrie or best pizza (grandmas’s only)”
H2
“best pizza”
H2
“White slice at Best Pizza”
H2
“They are both fantastic and you should eat both! Best has carmelized onions and a sesame seed crust.”
H2
“Best pizza was next, but this is where they started to disappoint.”
H2
“Best Pizza is a hidden gem, really exceptional veggie slice.”
H2
“white slice was hittin, margarita was hittin, beer was ice cold. It’s more then just about how good a slice is and they nail it”
H2
“best pizza in Williamsburg is worth a shot”
H2
“Love Best Pizza’s Grandma”
H2
“Best pizza Williamsburg White slice”
H2
“Best pizza has a great white slice, and feels very italian American 1950s.”
H2
“Best Pizza for their Grandma”
H2
“best pizza in Williamsburg”
H2
“Lots of people here recommend this place and it was worth it, vodka slice was the best one of the trip”
H2
“Their pizza is really good (my favorite), but I wouldn't call it crispy”
H2
“Best simultaneously v good and also overrated”
H2
“Best pizza is so so much better.”
H2
“Try the white slices at Fini and Best Pizza in the same neighborhood”
H2
“Best Pizza is my favorite slice shop in the city.”
H2
“Cheese slices at: Best Pizza”
H2
“Best Pizza for slices”
H2
“Best Pizza (for a more traditional NY slice).”
H2
“For straight cheese slice, probably Best Pizza. Perfectly crisp, love the flavor of the sauce, and high quality ingredients”
H2
“Best pizza in Williamsburg but a slice there, not delivered.”
H2
“Best Pizza is way overrated imo”
H2
“Best pizza is awesome”
H2
“Their grandma and the white slice are truly great”
H2
“IMO, a slice there is better than a whole pie.”
H2
“Best bang for buck/wait is Best Pizza, IMO.”
H2
“Best Pizza’s grandma slice is phenomenal and saucy.”
H2
“you can get equally great slices nearby at Fini, Ace’s, Best, and Tony’s”
H2
“I love the white slice at Best Pizza. So nice!”
H2
“Best Pizza’s veggie slice is a contender for my favorite ever.”
H2
“the slice was very underwhelming for top NYC pizza standards (L'industrie, Best, Fini, John's, Philomena)”
H2
“Best Pizza is great, and they do slices. A little pricey, but very tasty.”
H2