“IMO Luigi is a really great local slice.”
H3
All 352 rated mentions, most helpful first
“IMO Luigi is a really great local slice.”
H3
“Luigi’s is so inconsistent. Sometimes it’s mind bogglingly delicious other times the cheese and sauce are separate that it all pulls away on the first bite.”
H3
“The one time I went, it tasted sour. Not like sourdough sour (which I don't think they're using anyways) but like spoiled sour. I really disliked it.”
H3
“Good crust and tasty ingredients, but I've described them as a "snack" slice rather than a lunch slice because of how thin they are.”
H3
“Regular slice at Luigi's in south Park Slope”
H2
“PG, Joes, Luigis in BK, all standard NYC slice its great by NYC slice standards”
H2
“**3 Star:** Exceptional, worth a trip to another neighborhood.”
H2
“This was a really delicious slice. The crust was perfect.”
H2
“Fresh plain pie from Luigi's in Brooklyn. Maybe half pepperoni.”
H2
“and slice from Luigi’s in Park Slope”
H2
“Great place owned and operated by great people.”
H2
“Regular slice at Luigi's”
H2
“Luigi’s Pizza in South Slope. Walking in there is like a visit to the first pizzeria you went to as a kid (if you were a kid in the late 80s/early 90s).”
H2
“Just had Luigi’s in park slope and while had great flavor you can tell the slices had been sitting awhile.”
H2
“Luigis is a great classic slice.”
H2
“Luigi's grandma vodka slice kills”
H2
“best pizza around NY imo. All around amazing.”
H2
“where you can grab an excellent slice”
H2
“It is absolutely just a regular neighborhood spot. If you have limited time in NYC, do not waste your time going out of your way for pizza that can be gotten literally at any pizza joint.”
H2
“Luigi’s is best slice in the city”
H2
“Luigi's in Park Slope is my favorite classic slice.”
H2
“[Luigi's Pizza](https://maps.app.goo.gl/X7oQHsanq9N445Xg6) is the cheapest slice you can get for a pizza spot that gets listed in top 10 list pretty often. $2.75/slice so $8.25 for 3 slices.”
H2
“I found Luigi’s underwhelming. Not bad but not worth the subway trip.”
H2
“Luigi's is righteous pizza. Good job. Glad you enjoyed it.”
H2
“I think Luigi’s is great if you’re getting a pie, but slices are kind of underwhelming.”
H2
“A local OG no frills pizza shop that regularly makes Top 10 NYC Pizza lists.”
H2
“Luigis is better, Johns is better. It is a new york slice but doesn't have that perfect crisp that comes with the flatness that luigis has. And better sauce”
H2
“It's my favorite pizza slice in the city I've had so far, for the price. $5 for 2 excellent slices was my favorite weekend lunch.”
H2
“Luigi's in Brooklyn does a better classic NYC slice.”
H2
“Luigi’s in the South Slope is the platonic ideal of an old school slice joint.”
H2
“Luigi’s Park Slope regular slice.”
H2
“I think the problem a lot of people have is they get one slice. You really need to get a whole pie, ideally of their fresh motz.”
H2
“and love gio and luigi's. his pizza got me through much of the pandemic.”
H2
“Luigi’s is the quintessential NY slice”
H2
“Traditional NYC - Luigi’s”
H2
“go to luigis on 22nd in south slope. Classic NY slice shop.”
H2
“The places you mentions are good for different reasons. You don't go to Luigis for a specialty slice. You go there for a regular ny slice thats cheap.”
H2
“This is the slice you are looking for!”
H2
“slice at Luigi south slope”
H2
“Can’t beat the quality for the price if you want a simple slice”
H2
“Luigi's a great slice”
H2
“there's overflowing S tier pizza out there”
H2
“Their fresh mozzarella slice is my absolute favorite.”
H2
“Best fresh mozzarella slice, too! I’m a Park Slope resident and make many way down the block many many times a month.”
H2
“Luigis is a perfect NYC pizza though.”
H2
“It's a solid pizza joint amongst the dozens of solid pizza joints in NYC. If you're in the neighborhood, its a good option, but you can get the exact same slice at other places.”
H2
“Luigi’s in south slope has an amazing grandma slice”
H2
“a proper slice (Pauli gees or Luigi’s)”
H2
“I miss his fresh mozzarella slice/pie”
H2
“Luigi’s is next level. Best slice I’ve had. And I’ve had a plenty.”
H2