All 380 rated mentions, most helpful first
“Crust, sauce was perfect on the two regular slices. Flavor and crust was very good on the sicilian but it was a bit overcooked to my taste when it came to the crust. Too charred and inedibly hard but otherwise great. 9.5/10”
H3
“Lucia felt like the perfect ratio of sauce to cheese, perfect amount of stringiness, perfect chewiness, and perfect combination of technical execution with visceral enjoyment.”
H3
“Ended up waiting 20 extra minutes for a mediocre pizza slice that just wasn’t worth it to me. It was decent but nothing to go out of your way over.”
H3
“I thought Lucia in soho was bad. Cooked well and nice crisp but that was all to it. Sauce was bland, dough was bland.”
H3
“Lucia’s imo has outdone John’s. You can taste the freshness which makes a big difference. Plus the fresh basil and olive oil is a nice touch.”
H3
“Lucia is now the best pizza I’ve had in Manhattan”
H2
“Vodka slice at Lucia”
H2
“**3 Star:** Exceptional, worth a trip to another neighborhood.”
H2
“I liked the sauce at Lucia more than L’industrie. Feel like Lucia is underrated given how much hype L’industrie has”
H2
“Lucia is the clear winner. No wait. $3.80 a slice. And my favorite cheese slice of the trip!”
H2
“Kind of a quintessential NY slice. All components here just worked. Crust had great texture - good chew.”
H2
“Lucia is top tier pizza”
H2
“Lucia spinach is great.”
H2
“Favorite slices at the moment, all plain cheese slices.”
H2
“Lucia of Avenue X: clam”
H2
“マッシュルームで出来てるソースのかかってるPoblanoの旨味がすごかった。Cheeseも美味しかった”
H2
“the best plain cheese slice is L'Industrie in the West Village or Lucia of SoHo.”
H2
“Personally I thought the Spinach slice was okay, definitely worth a try but not too crazy about it.”
H2
“l'indutrie, Mama toos, Ceres, Lucia of Soho if you want pizza”
H2
“Slice: Lucia Pizza of SoHo (Caramelle Piccanti)”
H2
“All good slices.”
H2
“Lucia's in Soho truly is excellent and worth the walk.”
H2
“Lucia’s on X is my go to slice spot now”
H2
“Lucia pizza in SoHo is so good for a slice place, that I even enjoy the plain crust”
H2
“hit up Lucia in Soho. Never any line and it's just as good.”
H2
“if I'm getting pizza in Soho I'll go to Lucia.”
H2
“Lucia if you want the best slide in the area.”
H2
“Lucia Pizza of SoHo is slices and they’re bomb.”
H2
“They have the best tasting slices imo, but they are never hot-hot every time I get them.”
H2
“Then I must have gone on a good day. Perfectly crisp with great ratios.”
H2
“so definitely worth a try.”
H2
“Lucia of SoHo (on Canal) is a top 5 slice in Manhattan.”
H2
“Their best is actually their funghi and the spicy pepperoni”
H2
“Lucia of Soho really should be the top priority pizza on your list”
H2
“I feel like [Lucia of SOHO](https://maps.app.goo.gl/2XaFeM5yoyUS3tzY8) should be on your pizza list.”
H2
“Their regular white is good. Their white with cream of spinach is even better.”
H2
“if you're looking for a really good version of a classic slice, it's outstanding and reasonably priced for the quality.”
H2
“Spinach & Cheese were so good, sometimes you just get that "Hallelujah" moment in your mouth and here I got that”
H2
“Lucia soho is pretty great for slices.”
H2
“I must have gone on a bad day because I got the regular slice and it came out lukewarm with the cheese / basil 90% missing”
H2
“agreed, the crust is weak”
H2
“Have had pizza from the UES three times, and all were pretty subpar.”
H2
“I think the plain slice at Lucia’s is the best in the city.”
H2
“Lucia of soho, it’s a great representation of a good Brooklyn/nyc slice”
H2
“Cheese slices at: Best Pizza L'Industrie Lucia of SoHo”
H2
“Ehhhh, the pizza there isn’t amazing”
H2
“Lucia’s is fab but leans more Italian style with a usually softer crust, their caramels piccanti is fab.”
H2
“they still are my favorites: Pizza: a tie John’s on Bleecker and Lucia in Soho”
H2
“I would say Lucia Pizza is right there, but with a smaller line.”
H2
“for pizzas, L’industrie, lucia, rubirosa, or god forbids Lucaci are excellent options too”
H2