“Listen, it's good. That sauce is magical. Just know that it's gonna fall apart in your hands.”
H3
All 374 rated mentions, most helpful first
“Listen, it's good. That sauce is magical. Just know that it's gonna fall apart in your hands.”
H3
“The og spot in Brooklyn was our favorite, we always liked the wings too.”
H3
“And they also use the freshest whole leaf romaine, with amazing crunch, that just brings it all together. It's a bit of a "deconstructed" Caesar, but it's still one of my favorites.”
H3
“I was disappointed with Emily's burger. Super long wait and lots of gristle in the meat. The flavor was otherwise unremarkable.”
H3
“It's a decent burger but I was disappointed because of my high expectations. Personally I found it a tad sweet and the beef didn't taste like pure beef if that makes sense.”
H3
“I had a very very fat day earlier this year where I took a burger addict to Emily (mid af: their sauce tasted a bit off, bun didn’t have its usual give and their was no char. Unpleasant, really.”
H3
“The W. Village one is a fastfood style double cheeseburger, it's perfectly enjoyable, but nothing special.”
H3
“Their WV location has always had a rat problem. I lived in the neighborhood and they used to fail every inspection and had to shut down and hire exterminators. I would go to their other locations instead.”
H3
“Unfortunately the quality has declined in recent years and is so inconsistent now - often a wet mess - and there are so many other options, that it wouldn't be anywhere remotely near the top 5 now.”
H3
“I really didn't like their pizza. Maybe I went on an off day, but it was cracker-like and soggy at the same time.”
H3
“The burger itself was a generic puck burger and kinda dry (low fat content perhaps). No special cut or seasoning.”
H3
“It is however very delicious and probably the only place in town that you can get a heavy hitting burger and pizza combo.”
H2
“The Emily burger was good but a bit too rich not very balanced imo.”
H2
“The burger was quite good- but #1 burger in nyc? I’m not sure. I personally prefer the more thicker patty, medium rare style”
H2
“Emily: 7.25/10, very good burger, very good bun, limited toppings (including caramelized onion) work well together”
H2
“The sauce is amazing and I actually am a fan of the pretzel bun. It would rank higher if it wasn't all just way too much.”
H2
“We've been here the past three trips and have enjoyed it every time. We love the burger but aren't huge burger people so don't have anything to compare it to. Brussel sprout salad was excellent.”
H2
“Emily has a great burger”
H2
“And Emily serves a banging pizza.”
H2
“Emily in West Village has a bangin’ burger. Dry aged beef and you get great pizza as a bonus.”
H2
“I had Emily pizza 4 times in the first month I tried it.”
H2
“I agree-- I was wildly disappointed by that burger.”
H2
“If you haven’t tried Clinton Hill, it’s worth checking out, I’d put it one tier above their Detroit style”
H2
“The new locations are a joke compared to the original.”
H2
“I love the one at Emily West Village but it’s pretty anchovy forward so you have to like that.”
H2
“The Emmy burger is, in my opinion, the best burger I’ve ever eaten.”
H2
“I went Emily near Houston Street for the first time to try their Emmy Burger and was unimpressed. I was inspired to go from an Instagram post that noted this place as a top 5 burger in that part of town. The burger wasn’t seasoned the way I’d like and it was sloppy because of the sauce.”
H2
“I also really like the burger at Emily West Villlage , not really a smash burger though.”
H2
“Emily’s burger is really really fucking good”
H2
“Love the burger, but even better was when they used the leftover burger meat for breakfast burritos during the pandemic.”
H2
“Emily never makes NYC burger lists but its definitely up there.”
H2
“If you still want a good burger along your cheese cravings: Lords rarebit burger Pizza loves Emily’s Emmy burger”
H2
“Emily - the burger beat all the pizza for me.”
H2
“I really enjoy the burger at Emily in the West Village”
H2
“The burger at Emily is different and better than the one at Emmy Squared”
H2
“IMO the brooklyn location is much better, especially if you like saucy/juicier burgers”
H2
“Emily serves a good burger too in my opinion and the way they cook my burgers medium is always on point”
H2
“Emily Burger is uncomfortably messy for me.”
H2
“Honestly found it a little overrated and overpriced. Not bad but not particularly special.”
H2
“The Emily burger was good but a bit too rich not very balanced imo.”
H2
“Emily’s burger is fantastic.”
H2
“I also always recommend Emily’s for their burger.”
H2
“Both Emily and Peter Lugers burgers grossed me out.”
H2
“Emily (which I like better than 5G)”
H2
“I really liked the burger at Emily’s.”
H2
“My two favorite burgers are Emily and Pastis.”
H2
“Emily’s burger is terrible and gimmicky.”
H2
“The burger at Emily in Brooklyn was delicious. Haven’t had that many burgers since moving, but that would be towards the top anywhere I’ve lived.”
H2
“Emily for a restaurant burger”
H2
“The Emily pizza at Emily.”
H2