“The waiter then proceeded to forget to put in our order and never visited our table again. An hour or so later of watching other tables get their food, raised hell with the manager. Will never set foot in there ever again.”
H3
All 568 rated mentions, most helpful first
“The waiter then proceeded to forget to put in our order and never visited our table again. An hour or so later of watching other tables get their food, raised hell with the manager. Will never set foot in there ever again.”
H3
“It was an awful experience. Horrible waiter, they sat us at the smallest table where plates were hanging off the edges, and the steak (standard porterhouse) was not cooked properly.”
H3
“I've gotten the porterhouse many times at Wolfgang's and brought the leftovers home and they are outstanding reheated.”
H3
“Hot take but Wolfgang’s is the only steakhouse I’ve been to in the city that’s left me very disappointed. Ordered my steak medium rare and it came out blue, sent it back and it came out well done.”
H3
“last visit to a wolfgangs, i ordered a mid rare steak, came barely blue, refire came to the table blue again. i'm talking cold to the touch. never again”
H3
“Can confirm porterhouse for two was the move to go. I did took home 2 pieces of that steak and some spinach, and let's just say dinner was some of the best steak sandwich ever.”
H3
“I went to Wolfgang's (Broadway) and was disappointed. The food was ok. Honestly the steak was overcooked. Asked for medium rare and was def more medium. Service was chilly and a bit dismissive.”
H3
“Wolfgang (36th and park) location does a really good steak as well”
H2
“But Wolfgang’s steak is hard to beat.”
H2
“Can not get a better steak in Manhattan than Wolfgang’s.”
H2
“Not to mention, steakhouses are often getting the best cuts. Go look at a porterhouse from Wolfgang's and compare to your local butcher. Even high end well known butchers have porterhouses with tiny filets.”
H2
“Wolfgang’s makes a phenomenal tuna steak”
H2
“Hey, want Lugers porterhouse without all the BS (bad service, cash or Lugers cc, etc)? I've got you.”
H2
“Wolfgangs has some of the best steaks.”
H2
“For the classic NY porter house: Wolfgang's Tribeca”
H2
“Wolfgang's and Lugers have it down to get that charred crust and cooler rare plus center.”
H2
“Wolfgang is the best steak.”
H2
“Anecdotally had the most burnt but also contrarictory undercooked steak ever at Wolfgang's years back. Not sure how they did both.”
H2
“All of the above do excellent steaks in my opinion.”
H2
“Porterhouse at Wolfgang’s.”
H2
“I always recommend Wolfgang's in these situations. Your know what you're getting, it's delicious, I've had one overcooked steak out of probably 100, you can almost always get in.”
H2
“Wolfgang on park makes a great ribeye”
H2
“The best steakhouse in the walkable area is Wolfgang’s tribeca, which is their best location and a great rendition of a proper nyc steakhouse.”
H2
“For steak my husband and I love Wolfgang’s!”
H2
“If you want a New York style Porter House, go to Wolfgang's Tribeca”
H2
“I had really good onion rings at wolfgangs... probably the best part of the meal lmao”
H2
“For steak, I think Wolfgang's would be fine”
H2
“And the food and service are slightly better too”
H2
“Wolfgang - 7.5/10. Very good and side dishes are slightly better than average.”
H2
“Wolfgangs on park ave, porterhouse”
H2
“Their steaks are 90% as good as Lugers, with superior ambiance and service.”
H2
“You'll get pretty much the same ambiance and food quality without the attitude from the waitstaff.”
H2
“I don’t like the vibe, steak, or maybe most importantly, sides and apps at Wolfgang’s.”
H2
“Wolfgang’s tastes exactly the same but is more convenient to get to if you’re in Manhattan and accepts credit card.”
H2
“I also like Wolfgangs because they have TVs at the bar.”
H2
“We went to Wolfgang’s in SoHo last summer and it was a terrible experience. The porterhouse was poorly cooked and the service was awful. Never again.”
H2
“Wolfgang in Tribeca is miles better than the one in Midtown for whatever reason.”
H2
“Wolfgang's is much better than PL.o Imho , the porterhouse, German potatoes and others ...”
H2
“Best dinner I’ve had since the pandemic was at their Times Square location”
H2
“Wolfgangs porterhouse > hawksmoor”
H2
“I personally like the 33st Wolfgang’s because it’s an old subway station.”
H2
“Wolfgangs - Porterhouse for 2 (pretty much modeled from Luger)”
H2
“This right here, and in that order in terms of steak vs. setting.”
H2
“Dinner after show - Keens or Wolfgangs for steak.”
H2
“Wolfgang’s porterhouse is very on point.”
H2
“You can never really go wrong with Wolfgang's except for the one on Park which can be very loud”
H2
“German Potato’s at Wolfgang’s”
H2
“You can 100% get a res at Wolfgang's for tomorrow night (I checked Tribeca), while it's not the 'coolest' location, it's a classic old school white tablecloth steakhouse.”
H2
“There are other places that do steak well (like Wolfgang’s)”
H2
“Food is equally good downtown but the room isn’t as cozy and warm as midtown.”
H2