“I fell in love with this place. It may not be the most consistent or new age cold ferment dough magic but the variety, ingredient quality, excellent sauce and people make it.”
H3
All 664 rated mentions, most helpful first
“I fell in love with this place. It may not be the most consistent or new age cold ferment dough magic but the variety, ingredient quality, excellent sauce and people make it.”
H3
“Overall a tasty snack but the sauce is my real problem with it.”
H3
“Personally, I think Suprema's sauce is actually the best part of their plain slice. You get a real taste for it when you get their upside down. It's a bit on the sweeter side (likely due to some extra onions in the sauce) and very flavorful.”
H3
“I think this spot is so over rated. There is never enough turnover to get a fresh slice and the prices are too high.”
H3
“Prince St and Suprema are worth the hype”
H2
“Loved the pizza and the old-school atmosphere”
H2
“NY pizza suprema makes a mean upside down slice”
H2
“**3 Star:** Exceptional, worth a trip to another neighborhood.”
H2
“It's like a hiding in plain sight good pizzeria lol... Great spot to save $ instead of eating at MSG.”
H2
“NY Pizza Suprema is one of the better slice joints in the city as well.”
H2
“Great place for a classic NY slice”
H2
“Pizza was handed to us cold and flavors were meh even though I picked two that came fresh out of the oven. Would not go back, didn’t finish food.”
H2
“NY Pizza Suprema, two plain slices.”
H2
“Best true slice spot in that area of the city.”
H2
“NY Pizza Suprema is an excellent slice if you want to go the pizza route!”
H2
“the slices are good.”
H2
“suprema is genuinely worth the height”
H2
“Delivers better than it should.”
H2
“I personally like that it's saucy and not too cheesy”
H2
“Get pizza from Ny suprema, best slice shop near by.”
H2
“NY Pizza Suprema near Penn Station (slices, counter service)”
H2
“Favorite slices at the moment, all plain cheese slices.”
H2
“pizza supremo - closer to the garden but a perfect NYC slice”
H2
“NY Pizza Suprema is excellent if you're down for a slice”
H2
“Perhaps a slice from Vito’s or NY Pizza Suprema near Penn Station.”
H2
“NY suprema: classic Cheese or margarita”
H2
“Can’t go wrong with a slice from NY pizza Suprema.”
H2
“If you want a quick slice of delicious pizza.”
H2
“Pizza suprema”
H2
“IMO, arguably the best plain slice in NYC. Their upside down slice is also divine.”
H2
“My favorite quintessential slice.”
H2
“The best meatball slice”
H2
“good crisp, sauce bit overly sweet.”
H2
“it’s right next to Penn station but is one of the best greasy NY slice joints - not gourmet fancy, straight up NY slice”
H2
“Pizza suprema is delicious and so stupidly expensive.”
H2
“Pizza Suprema is definitely the best in that area!”
H2
“Pizza Suprema - get a regular and an upside down slice. If you like garlic and ricotta their white slice is killer if it's fresh.”
H2
“People shouldn’t sleep on Pizza Suprema. Right by Penn Station and a great variety of slices. The sauce is my favorite in NY”
H2
“Suprema probably has the best ratio of wait time to quality on this list”
H2
“This is the answer. Upside down slice.”
H2
“until then it's Pizza Suprema.”
H2
“Near times square, Pizza Suprema is pretty good.”
H2
“Pizza Suprema for pizza”
H2
“One of my favorite NYC pizzas.”
H2
“I find their pizza weirdly…wet”
H2
“Pizza Suprema is known for making a mean upside down slice. They also make an awesome plain slice”
H2
“Slice Joint - Pizza Suprema or Little Italy on 45th Street.”
H2
“NY Pizza Suprema probably the best pizza within walking distance of Chelsea”
H2
“For a top notch "upside down" slice Pizza Suprema by Penn Station is awesome (though not a cheap pizzeria, but among the best in Manhattan IMO).”
H2
“It's a solid slice”
H2