“It was just not a good experience. The quality of the staff seems to have gone in the same direction as Whole Foods did when Amazon acquired it.”
H3
All 526 rated mentions, most helpful first
“It was just not a good experience. The quality of the staff seems to have gone in the same direction as Whole Foods did when Amazon acquired it.”
H3
“Last time I went I ordered the trio sampler and all 3 of my pastas were undercooked (white in the middle) and I sent it back.”
H3
“Maybe unexpected, but prime rib sandwich at Eatly. Just thin sliced prime rib on focaccia with salt and olive oil. Ugh I want it everyday.”
H3
“The rest hasn’t changed either. Huge pasta selection, great cheeses, fresh mozzarella, etc. I’m still a fan.”
H3
“The sheep’s milk ricotta has ruined every other cannoli for me, cow’s milk doesn’t even come close”
H3
“2 delicious chickpea hummuses, a hearty salad with tuna. That's 4-6 lunches easy.”
H3
“Out comes 1 single cube of tuna barely an inch high and 2 inches by 2 inches. My friends and I just looked at one another like, that’s it? We were so pissed that we chose the tuna over getting ice cream.”
H3
“This time, it was shockingly mediocre. The bread they’re using now is some soft sesame roll with no bite or crumb.”
H3
“Eataly has a lot going for it, but it can feel rushed.”
H3
“The last three times I had it, it was such a letdown. Terrible bread (sesame?!), under-salted, overcooked meat.”
H3
“Felt like it was wildly overrated for $30. Not as juicy as I thought and bread was falling apart and maybe even stale. Did I miss something? I heard all the hype too but sadly disappointed.”
H3
“it's the best gelato I've had so far in NY. Best texture by far and closest to the amazing gelato I've tried in Bologna.”
H3
“It was the typical bread they give you anywhere else with your meal.”
H2
“Eataly is pretty good and legit (Native Italian here) but so shamefully expensive”
H2
“You might want the Lavazza cafe at Eataly The baristas & service are awful, but you'll get a pull of Italy's most emblematic roast”
H2
“Buy an American wagyu at Eataly and cook it yourself. 2x the quality and the company is always on point”
H2
“Bought a Pannetone from Eataly and it exceeded expectations.”
H2
“Dessert: Eataly sheep’s milk cannoli”
H2
“I had the bolognese at Eataly and it was the most ridiculously tiny bowl, appetizer sized portion of pasta for $26+tax+tip. Absolutely ridiculous IMO”
H2
“**Eataly** - nice cheese, mostly Italian, but definitely not limited to Italian cheeses”
H2
“Eataly have good coffee. One of the few I actually enjoyed.”
H2
“they have a decent range of imported Italian butters and an incredible cheese counter.”
H2
“I just had Eataly’s cacio e Pepe kit from a Too Good To Go bag and can attest to it being very good.”
H2
“You get the speck and it’s not dry on the edges from low turnover like most places.”
H2
“they treated me like dirt because I was dining solo and didn’t want to drink”
H2
“I'm going to catch flack for this, but at the price point Eataly consistently has great quality mozzarella.”
H2
“eataly has a great one if you’re buying to go”
H2
“Go to Eataly and pick up salads and sandwiches. Or breads and cheese and salumi.”
H2
“In fact I think it’s the best tiramisu in the city. Signed, a tiramisu buff”
H2
“Hit up Eataly for literally any Italian prepared food.”
H2
“The cannoli at Eataly are shockingly good.”
H2
“Eatatly is still one of my favorites, nothing else has compared.”
H2
“I like the prime rib sandwich and I always enjoy the cannoli dessert. The pastas are solid, too.”
H2
“Got a extremely expensive pizza with prosciutto on it from Eataly and it was awful”
H2
“they ignore and disdain me and make it super clear. This has happened at least four times over the last month and a half.”
H2
“But their tiramisu is truly the best non restaurant tiramisu I’ve had in NYC”
H2
“tiramisu (SO GOOD, one of the best tiramisu i've had)”
H2
“Eataly will have great options for you, along with kid-friendly atmosphere.”
H2
“the staff member wouldn’t let me order the amount I wanted because I’d told her it was for two people and “two people can’t eat that much.””
H2
“For a coffee and a pastry ok.”
H2
“Eataly has great dry aged steaks.”
H2
“Expensive but amazing range and always fresh.”
H2
“at least at Eataly they have the nice selection of chicories and radicchios and mushrooms (even the kinds that the farmer’s market doesn’t stock)”
H2
“Eataly but it’s more expensive.”
H2
“Eataly for a splurge (pricier, but also will give you that restaurant hand-made feeling; and still cheaper than at the restaurant)”
H2
“In all honesty in the past I have gotten some good steak there.”
H2
“A cake from Eataly (they have nice elegant boxes)”
H2
“Eataly Tiramisu”
H2
“The rotisserie stall in Eataly Flatiron also had quality porchetta by the pound last time I checked.”
H2
“Their proscuitto and cheeses are amazing.”
H2