“Service was impeccable, I’ve never experienced such great hospitality. food was excellent and I was full af after.”
H3
All 1,368 rated mentions, most helpful first
“Service was impeccable, I’ve never experienced such great hospitality. food was excellent and I was full af after.”
H3
“I can honestly say this was the best burger of my life. The juiciness, the flavor, the slight sweetness—for such a simple burger with just three ingredients, it was absolutely incredible!”
H3
“Overall Rating - 4/5; My Michelin Rating - 2*; Would I Recommend - Absolutely! This restaurant is all about putting great ingredients and good flavor combinations on the plate, and they certainly succeed at that!”
H3
“Hubs and I went here to celebrate our anniversary and it was a great experience. The butternut squash lasagna with brown butter and picked peppers was the standout dish for me (left on pic 2), but all of it was delicious, even the rolls they brought out between courses.”
H3
“They brought the wrong wine for 3 of the 5 courses. They would pour it, then a few minutes later come over with an apology and a new glass with the correct pairing. Not complaining since hey free wine, but certainly didn’t expect that many errors.”
H3
“The onion bread they give you is incredible. Burger is great but can go more interesting for first time.”
H3
“I had the worst experience at Gramercy Tavern. We were ignored for the first 20 minutes then waiters came flying in and processed us through the whole experience with cold, brutal efficiency.”
H3
“From start to finish just a sublime experience.”
H3
“the food is solid, but it’s not some world changing culinary experience”
H3
“Ah, my favorite as well. Been going since.... 2012 I think. Love their tasting menu.”
H3
“I was just there and was a bit disappointed. The portion sizes were too small for a $175, 5 course tasting with multiple vegan items.”
H3
“Love Gramercy Tavern! They have always put a premium on service, and to me, it’s exactly the experience I want in a high-end restaurant; professional, attentive without being hovering, and warm and welcoming.”
H3
“The wine pairings in the dining room were generous, overall a great experience.”
H3
“it was an amazing night. It’s a cozy place and the food was really delicious and the service was excellent.”
H3
“Grammercy Tavern has the best burger. I used to love Au Cheval and thought that their chessburger was the best but then I tried Grammercy and it was everything that I wanted in a burger: juicy, right size and the perfect balance between the patty, cheese and bacon. It is 35$ but so worth it!”
H3
“for desserts: semifreddo, peach cake, lemon cake and the cookie are excellent”
H3
“The one bite I can't stop thinking about is a brown butter, sweet potato agnolotti from Gramercy Tavern that I took an ugly picture of and didn't include. The filling seemed impossible light.”
H3
“Looking back I should have griped at the time but it really was egregious. Service was a little uneven too (mixed up orders, drinks not arriving for 20 mins, etc)”
H3
“I ate at Gramercy Tavern recently and enjoyed it! The main dining room has a five course tasting menu, which is enough to give variety and feel special but doesn’t drag on like some fancy dinners. And the food was elevated yet accessible.”
H3
“Mine had a white slice of cheese that didn’t have much flavor, I specifically looked for an aioli and didn’t find any trace of it, and definitely no hot pepper.”
H3
“We ended up at Gramercy Tavern, and loved it. Very gluten friendly and an overall great experience.”
H3
“They comp’d all my drink and brought me the best little cake (twice because they dropped it when I moved seats to chat with some other people at the bar lol).”
H3
“The chicken liver mousse was great and desserts were amazing but all the entrees were bland, overcooked, or dry.”
H3
“The starters (seafood, oysters) and finishers (flan) were excellent, however the middle of the pack entrees were not especially inspiring at their price point.”
H3
“it was probably the most disgusting meal I've ever had in my life. The chicken was cooked sous vide style and was just essentially a boiled piece of chicken that wasn't browned in any sense.”
H3
“Absolutely tremendous. There might not be a better bang for your buck nice meal in the city. The Butternut Squash Lumache may have been my favorite pasta dish in a city full of them.”
H2
“Loved it!!! Only 1 star and probably as good or even better then Bernardin in my opinion. Easy to get a table, great service, but also relaxed. You can eat calmly, have a glass of wine and try great food - balanced, rich in flavor and warm”
H2
“It’s a really good burger, not sure it’s worth a dinner when I’ve only got three nights, but it’s a good time.”
H2
“I couldn’t be happier with my decision to eat at the Gramercy Tavern. I wanted to order the cheddar biscuits but something deep within me told me to get the salad for an app and it did not disappoint. It was beautiful and delicious.”
H2
“3. Burger at Gramercy Tavern”
H2
“Worth it: atera, Ko, gramercy tavern”
H2
“but a handful have received Michelin stars and are a great value.”
H2
“Gramercy Tavern. Don't even bother with the dining room - the tavern is lovely and has a great menu.”
H2
“Food always solid and great service.”
H2
“The best bread and butter i’ve had was at gramercy tavern. It was goat cheese butter with the most perfect dinner roll ever.”
H2
“Their burger is 100”
H2
“Union Square Cafe or Gramercy Tavern both have great burgers and oysters.”
H2
“Remarkably excellent and consistent food and dining experience, especially in the tavern (though the main dining room is also great). They're still extremely popular but they've been around long enough that they're not mega trendy or influencer-y. Probably my all around favorite restaurant in NYC. It's honestly amazing how good they still are after all these years.”
H2
“I enjoyed the food (burger and dessert) very much - probably one of the top burgers I had so far in the city. However, it puzzles me as to how little people factor in the price of the items in their reviews and recommendations.”
H2
“Gramercy tavern , eat alone they use to give you. Glass of champagne”
H2
“I've been going for 10 years and never had less than a perfect experience. It's my top choice for birthdays/celebrations because I know they won't mess it up!”
H2
“Fantastic vibe in the Tavern Room. Outstanding food. Seabass was excellent. Xtra side of broccoli was truly crazy good for brocc. Broiled oysters very tasty. Two desserts - both OUTSTANDS.”
H2
“Tavern room at Gramercy Tavern for the burger and whatever else catches your eye”
H2
“I was thoroughly satisfied, it did not feel at all like the restaurant was cutting corners for RW. It truly was a Michelin star experience for $60.”
H2
“I found the Gramercy Tavern staff to be some of the friendliest staff I’ve ever had at a top tier restaurant. Great burger too.”
H2
“The tavern room at Gramercy Tavern. Great burger, really beautiful restaurant, great pasty chef and extensive dessert menu.”
H2
“The closest I've found to this type of burger in NYC so far is Gramercy Tavern - it's a solid, clean burger that's made with high quality ingredients and not overly greasy”
H2
“Have been going to GT for several decades and it's still one of my favorites. It's reliable with impeccable service and a creative menu, and I've never had a lackluster experience there.”
H2
“Gramercy 100%. Burger is amazing but not so rich that it’s naptime after”
H2
“gramercy tavern burger is very good, the duck fat chips are a real star”
H2