Baked in Brooklyn

6.8/10

AI-generated summary

Get a . People say they run about three times the size of a normal one, crispy outside and doughy inside, and the Oreo and the plain glazed both get named. The and the bread, Pullman loaves and challah, come up too. Not everyone is sold, some call it a solid neighborhood bakery and nothing more, and the gets forgotten.

755 5th Ave, BrooklynSunset Park, BrooklynGoogle Maps

What Reddit says9

View all

in:What are your top single donuts (not locations) that you’ve tasted in the city?1 pts
“Baked in Brooklyn's Oreo donut is spectacular enough to bring me in all the way to Park slope from Staten whenever the craving gets too bad. It's easily 3x the size of any other donut, crispy on the outside, doughy on the inside, and generously topped.”
H3
in:Donuts or Doughnuts? Tour1 pts
“My personal fave plain glazed is from Baked in Brooklyn They're huge and substantial while still feeling fluffy and not overly dense. They do a black and white donut that I dream about.”
H3
postEverything I ate in NYC in one week (visiting from the UK)162 pts
“Cool place that gives a free baked good with your coffee. It was very popular but I cannot remember how the coffee or pastry tasted at all, so it definitely didn't blow me away. **3/5**”
H2
in:Are there any local bakeries that sell bread that is like the equivalent of the square grocery store sandwich bread?2 pts
“Baked in Brooklyn on 5th Ave has delicious Pullman loaves”
H2
in:Chocolate birthday cake?2 pts
“their chocolate ganache cake is the best I’ve ever tried”
H2
in:Where can I get an unsliced square loaf of bread? Like the kind you buy at the store that comes in a bag, but unsliced.1 pts
“Baked in Brooklyn has great unsliced square challah loaves”
H2

See all 9 mentions