Siena Pizza

All 9 rated mentions, most helpful first

post5 days in NYC202 pts
“classic slice and Nutella cannoli (6/10 cannoli 10/10 pizza)”
H2
in:Pizza Recommendations -Downtown2 pts
replying to u/Jakoobus91: My wife and I went to Siena Pizza on Rector Street after we went to the 9/11 memorial last year when we were in town. Idk how locals view the place but us midwesterners thought it was pretty damn good. It's also walking distance so that was nice.
“Solid local spot and underrated.”
H2
in:5 days in NYC1 pts
“classic slice and Nutella cannoli (6/10 cannoli 10/10 pizza)”
H2
in:Lunch spots in FiDi/Chinatown3 pts
“Places I enjoyed grabbing lunches at whenever in FiDi.”
H1
in:Pizza Recommendations -Downtown2 pts
“us midwesterners thought it was pretty damn good”
H1
in:Manhattan’s Best2 pts
“Siena Pizza on Rector St.”
H1
in:Reigning pizza slice downtown Manhattan? L’industrie?1 pts
“I love Siena Pizza”
H1
in:Where can I still get great knots (Slice joints, not Radio Bakery or sit-down)1 pts
“Siena Pizza in FiDi.”
H1
in:Bringing my dad to get stoned at Mercer Labs and then to the Comedy Cellar. What should we eat in between?-1 pts
replying to u/Annual_Judge_7272: Joes pizza nothing else
“hit up Siena pizza instead”
H1