City Diner

All 9 rated mentions, most helpful first

in:The most overrated, overpriced pancakes in NYC!!! Biggest waste of $27 bucks2 pts
“City Diner on 90th and Broadway on the Upper West Side has great pancakes at a fraction of what OP paid.”
H2
in:Name a place to eat at thats nasty af but people hype tf out of it1 pts
replying to u/kneelbeforeplantlady: Seconded. Metro diner used to be a second home for me when I was studying, then I went twice after covid and I’ve never been back.
“has a similar vibe/aesthetic, and is still quite good”
H2
in:Which diners can I visit while on vacation in NYC to get the authentic American diner experience?1 pts
“The pancake combo is a classic.”
H2
in:If you could only pick one restaurant in Manhattan to visit and one to definitely avoid, what would they be?1 pts
“the food was barely passable and wayyyy too expensive for what it was.”
H2
in:If you could bring back one restaurant, cafe, bodega, etc. that went out of business, which one would it be?25 pts
“Kelley & Ping, Republic, La Petite Abeille, City Diner…”
H1
in:What’s a Really Good Diner?14 pts
“Some of my favorites that are thankfully still around: Family Corner on Ditmars in Astoria. Gracie's Diner and Ritz Diner on UES. Flame diner near Lincoln Center, City Diner on UWS.”
H1
in:Recommend me your go to diner, mine’s jumped the shark11 pts
“Cafe 82 or City Diner on 90th”
H1
in:Recommend me your go to diner, mine’s jumped the shark9 pts
replying to u/Blue_foot: Cafe 82 or City Diner on 90th
“City Diner is by far my favorite local diner”
H1
in:Help us find the BEST DINER in NYC - we want to feel like in a movie1 pts
“City Diner on Broadway and 90th might fit the bill.”
H1