Cousin John's Cafe & Bakery

All 12 rated mentions, most helpful first

in:Best places for pie?2 pts
replying to u/mayshebeablessing: Cousin John’s in Park Slope
“Their apple crumbcake is my kryptonite.”
H2
in:Who has the best Strawberry Shortcake in the city?2 pts
“Cousin John's in Park Slope does a good strawberry shortcake.”
H2
in:Good breakfast spots1 pts
“Cousin John's is a nice eatery in park slope that does amazing pancakes and omelettes!”
H2
in:Bakery Crawl Suggestions70 pts
“Cousin John’s”
H1
in:Best places for pie?3 pts
“Cousin John’s in Park Slope”
H1
in:Who has the best Strawberry Shortcake in the city?2 pts
replying to u/cawfytawk: Cousin John's in Park Slope does a good strawberry shortcake. They also sell slices.
“came here to rec cousin john’s!”
H1
in:Favorite restaurants to get just desserts in Brooklyn?2 pts
“Good variety.”
H1
in:Dessert for Friendsgiving1 pts
“Cousin John’s in park slope !”
H1
in:Best dessert place in Times Square1 pts
replying to u/QUINNFLORE: juniors to-go cheesecake
“My top cheesecake recs in rough order are Veniero's, Chelsea Square Diner, Juliana's (Cousin John's in BK), Katz's (S&S in Bronx), Remedy Diner, Gallaghers, and Keen's (too much gelatin IMO).”
H1
in:Look to the cookie: Best Black & White?1 pts
“some of their stuff is mid so keep being hesitant.”
H1
in:Rainbow cookie crawl. (14 bakeries, Queens, Manhattan, and Brooklyn)1 pts
“Cousin John’s on 7 Ave Brooklyn amazing can’t be beat”
H1
in:Bakery Crawl Suggestions0 pts
replying to u/air-: Agree with most of this, but would add La Bicyclette in Williamsburg and drop Mei Lai Wah
“It’s an ok neighborhood bakery - nothing more, nothing less.”
H1