“The shame of it is that they have an amazing menu of sandwiches that are so much better than a wrap you can get at just about any deli in the city.”
H3
All 61 rated mentions, most helpful first
“The shame of it is that they have an amazing menu of sandwiches that are so much better than a wrap you can get at just about any deli in the city.”
H3
“It's OK, but not nearly as good as it used to be. Got an Italian hero there a couple months back, and there was a lot less meat on it. It was a fine sandwich, but certainly not something I would rave about to anyone.”
H3
“It’s fine, but after ordering sandwiches there consistently for a few months I started to notice how cheap and low quality some of the ingredients they use there. One time I had a chunk of freezer burnt chicken in my chicken parm.”
H3
“Maybe an unpopular opinion but I went to UES location recently and did NOT like it at all. I had a sandwich and the bread was hard, deli meat was tough and not good, and the price nearly made me cry.”
H3
“Just wanted to shout-out the amazing sandwich that is the Amore from Milano Market (UES).”
H2
“I had the chicken caesar wrap from the UES it was straight salad and croutons.”
H2
“this wrap was a little less than mediocre at best.”
H2
“Regina’s Grocery is better than Milano Market on the UES”
H2
“Italian sandwich: Milano market, Regina’s Grocery”
H2
“I love their sandwiches”
H2
“They have an eggplant on olive focaccia that I really like, but I’m not traveling to get it.”
H2
“I used to live a few blocks from there and I still make the trip uptown to get a Milano Special when the craving hits.”
H2
“Their amore sandwich is incredible”
H2
“awesome sandwiches and a great selection of prepared salads, pasta, meats, cheese.”
H2
“Milano Market on the UES has a great vegetarian selection. My longtime favorite is eggplant, fresh mozzarella, onions tomatoes and herb mayo on olive focaccia.”
H2
“Amazing, giant sandwiches”
H2
“Tbh I feel like Milano’s chicken caesar wrap is pretty overrated but I’ve only had them from UES location.”
H2
“I like the salads from Milano Market”
H2
“Milano Market is great for italian sandwiches.”
H2
“Milanos is overrated/overpriced.”
H2
“Milano Market for great sandwiches.”
H2
“Overrated: Pil Pil, JG Melon, Milano Market”
H2
“Caesar wrap and their brussel sprouts. Both so good”
H2
“The chicken Caesar wrap is so 90s in the very best way”
H2
“I think the chicken is bland and overcooked at the UES one. I really don’t get the hype at all.”
H2
“The Dalton at the UES Milano Market.”
H2
“I love me a Milano Special. I was a regular at the UES location when I lived up there.”
H2
“Quality of UES one has gone downhill since the chicken Caesar wrap went viral. It is way overhyped.”
H2
“Comfortland or Milano market UES Hands down. I’ve tried them all trust me.”
H1
“Milano market for sandwiches (pick them up and then walk to Central Park for a picnic)”
H1
“it's a fantastic sandwich shop imo.”
H1
“Milano market”
H1
“Listen, it's great. It's just really freaking heavy and indulgent.”
H1
“That stuff was the truth”
H1
“It was pretty good, not something I'd need to get again.”
H1
“Tamam, xian famous foods, Milano market, 7th st burger, dig.”
H1
“Can’t help myself but talk shit to people ordering the chicken Cesar salad wrap there. Know where you are”
H1
“Milano Market but I can only vouch for the one on the east side.”
H1
“Came here to say this, it’s my go to combo when hitting the park.”
H1
“Cafe Sabarsky, HUSO, Noz Market, Caffe Buon Gusto, JG Melon, Sant Ambroeus Madison, abcV, Milano Market, Schaller's Stub Sausage Bar, 7th Street Burger”
H1
“Besides the Joe bastianich sandwich chain I’ve found these are comparable: Cappone's Italian Sandwich Shop and Salumeria in the west village Milano’ Market 89th & 3rd Sergimmo Salumeria in midtown on 9th Ave. Best Sicily Bottega in FiDi”
H1
“Milanos on UES is legit”
H1
“Tha Phraya, Up Thai, Milano Market, Gracie Mews Diner, Bagel Shop, Chez Nick, Orwashers, Water & Wheat, Marinars”
H1
“Milano market is super overrated. Don’t expect an authentic Italian deli, it instead poses as one.”
H1
“I agree. I prefer yorkville deli for $ to enjoyment ratio. Not saying yorkville deli is anything special.”
H1
“Milano is incredible!!!! Highly highly HIGHLY recommend”
H1
“Milano is great.”
H1
“milano market east side location. TRUST. ME.”
H1
“Agree - it is very mid, like something you’d get at a decent gas station”
H1
“When weather permits, my husband and I like to fuck up a sandwich from there in Central Park and then go to an art museum.”
H1