Rosemary's Pantry

All 8 rated mentions, most helpful first

in:Best chicken parm sub in NYC?1 pts
“They make it fresh to order and often put two chicken milanese. They also put a good quality cheese that's melted right.”
H3
in:Favourite restaurant in NYC?14 pts
“its probably the best thing I can get within a 5 minutes walk. The sandwich is always made fresh to order and they udnerstand a good sandwich has a meat to bread ratio greater than 1.”
H2
in:If you could bring back one closed restaurant, what would it be?4 pts
“The main reason is they had an amazing chicken parm sub that I miss dearly”
H2
in:Favourite restaurant in NYC?2 pts
replying to u/team_suba: Is that the place on first that has the huge corner property ? Or is rosemarys pantry something different
“The chicken parm sandwich at Rosemary's Pantry is their best item imo”
H2
in:What’s an absolute gem of a place you don’t hear talked about very much in the city? 2 pts
“Rosemarys pantry, which is attached to Rosemary's east has an absolutely phenomenal chicken parm sandwich for 14 or 15$.”
H2
in:Cheap & Tasty food recs in downtown manhattan1 pts
“Its freshly made on house bread, with two chicken milanese or one large one, tomato sauce and fresh cheese. I lived off of that on my work from home days last year.”
H2
in:Chicken parm hero for lunch4 pts
“My favorite was rosemarys pantry which is a coffee shop attached to rosemarys east in stuytown. I still think about it.”
H1
in:Best chicken parm sub in NYC?1 pts
“Rosemary’s Pantry, by Peter Cooper Village.”
H1