The Carnegie Club

All 10 rated mentions, most helpful first

in:Classic NYC cocktail bar that gives NYC vibes?1 pts
replying to u/beernerd6: Carnegie Club The Campbell The bar at Smith and Wollensky Monkey Bar The Bar room at the Beeckman Hotel PJ Clark’s upstairs (original location) Bar at The Polo Bar The back room at Grand Central Oyster Bar
“+1 for the Carnage Club. They make an excellent barreled old fashioned.”
in:Classic NYC cocktail bar that gives NYC vibes?32 pts
“Carnegie Club”
in:Old New York restaurants (Mad Men era) 24 pts
“Carnegie Club (more of a bar)”
in:Annual guys dinners at Keens. Thinking about changing it up.15 pts
“Carnegie Club is a great spot.”
in:Annual guys dinners at Keens. Thinking about changing it up.4 pts
replying to u/beernerd6: I like Strip House — downtown location. Other options include Barclay Rex, Merchant Cigar Bar, Carnegie Club.
“Second to Carnegie club for afters”
in:Best Restaurant with Experience?2 pts
“Carnegie Club”
in:Bar for whiskey and jazz that isn't a jazz club?2 pts
“Carnegie Club”
in:Fave Midtown NYC Cozy Bars2 pts
“Tomi Jazz, Carnegie Club, Agency of Record”
in:Annual guys dinners at Keens. Thinking about changing it up.1 pts
“Carnegie Club is a good cigar bar in the 50s on the East Side”
in:Where to take parents? (2nd time in NYC)1 pts
replying to u/DizzyDumpling: Can't beat the view at Manhatta. Some New York classics - Balthazar, River Cafe (also great view, take the ferry), Cafe Luxembourg. Libertine is newer but has a great French bistro feel. Chinese food in NYC is way better than London - Cafe China and Cheli are both a bit more upscale.
“Also try Carnegie Club”