OddFellows Ice Cream Co.

All 13 rated mentions, most helpful first

postSoft serve in NYC348 pts
“another great pistachio soft serve option if you’re in Dumbo.”
H2
in:Where to go for first date in Brooklyn?21 pts
“oddfellows or ample hill ice cream”
H2
in:What's your favorite place in NYC to get ice cream in?20 pts
replying to u/Serialsnackernyc: Some faves include Anita, caffe panna, Chinatown ice cream factory, malai
“Oddfellows (for in shop scoops only the factory pints are lame)”
H2
in:Fancy/Iconic Dessert Recommendations1 pts
“Oddfellows’ passionfruit apricot pistachio!”
H2
in:Best dessert in nyc?1 pts
“Oddfellows Passionfruit Apricot Pistachio ice cream”
H2
in:Best Dessert around Dumbo/ Bk Heights/ Cobble Hill?1 pts
“Oddfellows if you like ice cream - I think it's on Water St.”
H2
in:What's your favorite place in NYC to get ice cream in?18 pts
“Oddfellows”
H1
in:What's your favorite place in NYC to get ice cream in?13 pts
“Oddfellows”
H1
in:Best mint choc chip ice cream?7 pts
“These are some of the ones I enjoy! Haagen- Dazs. Van Leeuwan. Oddfellows.”
H1
in:Best food on a budget in nyc? 3 pts
“Oddfellows (recommend if you go to domino park)”
H1
in:Good eats for families1 pts
replying to u/urbanstoop88: This is great advice. The Time Out Market in dumbo is kind of cringey but it’s awesome for kids - Clinton Street Baking Company is so good. You can combine it with a walk across the Brooklyn Bridge or a ferry ride!
“And there is great ice cream thereabouts too. Sugar Hill Creamery, Oddfellows and my favorite, the Brooklyn Ice Cream Factory.”
H1
in:Help my food crawl1 pts
replying to u/OkPerformance6864: I’d say replace Van Leeuwen with Caffe Panna for something more unique (and better imo)
H1
in:What’s your favorite dessert place and order in NYC?1 pts
“I also like Oddfellows.”
H1