“Sicily Osteria would be my rec in the area for Italian, not your typical Italian menu but lots of options and everything I’ve had there has been great!”
H2
6.9/10Italian
AI-generated summary
Good Italian right by Times Square, which people say is rare. Two posters brought Italian relatives who called it legit, and regulars rate it over the old guard spots nearby. One person went twice and said the second visit was bad.
“Sicily Osteria would be my rec in the area for Italian, not your typical Italian menu but lots of options and everything I’ve had there has been great!”
H2
“Sicily Osteria is very good. A newer place and better than many of the old guard (lattanzi, becco, etc). Went with a friend from southern Italy who’s in the restaurant business and he also said it was very good and authentic.”
H2
“It has a very nice atmosphere, service, and food.”
H2
“Carmines, Tratoria Trecolori, bucca di beppo, Don Angie, Sicily Osteria, Eccolo, La Masseria and a little further Normas Hell’s Kitchen which would be worth it.”
H1
“There’s Sicily Osteria in midtown which is actually really good. Went with brother in law who’s Italian and he’s said it’s legit.”
H1