Hartley's

All 16 rated mentions, most helpful first

in:Where Are Your Favorite Cozy, Quaint NYC Pubs/ Bars?2 pts
“Hartley's in Brooklyn should hit the mark, but keep in mind if it's good pour and cozy, it can get very crowded very quick. Great vibe either way.”
H2
in:Best popcorn in the city?1 pts
“Hartley’s in Clinton Hill makes a great box of buttery cheese covered popcorn.”
H2
in:What are places in NYC that match this winter cozy vibe?1 pts
replying to u/theillustratedlife: Do they do Xmas decorations for the winter, or is it just generally cozy? I'm not much of a bar person, but Hartley's looks well-loved also.
“Hartley’s is also a good bet, especially if you like Guinness.”
H2
in:Great British style or Irish pub?36 pts
“Hartley’s in Brooklyn is really the perfect Irish Pub.”
H1
in:Brooklyn Neighborhood of the Week: Prospect Heights, Fort Greene and Clinton Hill10 pts
“Hartley's for a great Irish bar”
H1
in:Seeking legit Irish pub food in Dtwn BK9 pts
“Hartleys in Clinton Hill”
H1
in:Welcome to the Irish Pub-aissance: The New Irish Pubs Are Embracing Their Irish Roots6 pts
“Hartley’s is the best Irish pub I think I’ve been to in recent memory.”
H1
in:Seeking legit Irish pub food in Dtwn BK3 pts
replying to u/Salty_Simmer_Sauce: Hartleys in Clinton Hill
“Second this!”
H1
in:Seeking legit Irish pub food in Dtwn BK3 pts
replying to u/Salty_Simmer_Sauce: Hartleys in Clinton Hill
“Was just talking about this place yesterday! So good”
H1
in:Where Are Your Favorite Cozy, Quaint NYC Pubs/ Bars?2 pts
replying to u/InstructionNo3616: Hartleys
“They came to mind immediately for me!”
H1
in:Non-Americans of NYC -- which restaurant in the city has the best version/showcase of your home country's food?1 pts
“Hartley’s in Clinton Hill.”
H1
in:Great British style or Irish pub?1 pts
“Hartleys and Joneswood are the best”
H1
in:Where Are Your Favorite Cozy, Quaint NYC Pubs/ Bars?1 pts
replying to u/Queasy-Guard-4774: Too bad the service at Swift is terrible and their Guinness pours are bad. ://
“Hartley’s!”
H1
in:Where Are Your Favorite Cozy, Quaint NYC Pubs/ Bars?1 pts
replying to u/InstructionNo3616: Hartleys
“This is the one”
H1
in:Where Are Your Favorite Cozy, Quaint NYC Pubs/ Bars?1 pts
“Hartleys in Clinton Hill!”
H1
in:Where Are Your Favorite Cozy, Quaint NYC Pubs/ Bars?1 pts
“Hartleys”
H1