“It's just bread. Not even slightly chewy and lacks that unique aftertaste bagels have. The salmon is also not fresh and a little crusty. Just really bad overall.”
H3
5.5/10
AI-generated summary
People argue about this one. Fans say the bagels are plump and made on site, and they like the herbed sourdough and the in the morning. Critics say it's just bread with no chew and that the isn't fresh. Neighborhood people still treat it as the go to.
“It's just bread. Not even slightly chewy and lacks that unique aftertaste bagels have. The salmon is also not fresh and a little crusty. Just really bad overall.”
H3
“Bagels on the square are terrible.”
H2
“bagels on the square is actually top 2 bagel I have ever had.”
H2
“That’s my go to spot since I live in the area.”
H2
“Bagels on the Square IS great, especially their herbed sourdough bagel (which is worth a try if you want to switch it up!)”
H2
“Bagels on the square is great. One of the few places to do steak on a bagel sandwich in the morning.”
H2
“Plump bagels like I like them. Made on site and cream cheese too. Great variety!”
H2
“Downtown I like Tompkins square bagels, Murray’s, David’s and bagels on the square.”
H2
“Bagels on the Square. Or Greenbergs are where people who live in the neighborhood go.”
H2