Johnny’s Reef

6.1/10

AI-generated summary

Cheap at picnic tables on the water, plus a or a henny colada. People say the food is fine rather than great and they go for the setting. It's a pain to reach without a car, so treat it like a day trip. Sammy's and Tony's Pier next door are about the same.

2 City Island Ave, BronxCity Island, BronxGoogle Maps

What Reddit says21

in:Bronx8 pts
“I love cheap fried seafood and cheap pina coladas on City Island at Johnny’s.”
H2
in:Best fried whole belly clams? I am not very knowledgeable about NY seafood spots5 pts
“the seafood is generally good”
H2
in:Shrimp, Soft Shell Crab, and Piña Coladas from Johnny’s Reef3 pts
“Their pina colada slaps”
H2
in:Favorite seafood restaurants?2 pts
“Johnny’s Reef on City Island is also iconic for fried seafood!”
H2
in:Shrimp, Soft Shell Crab, and Piña Coladas from Johnny’s Reef2 pts
“Love their fried lobster tails!”
H2
in:The summer always makes me crave fried foods for some reason. What are either some of the most exemplary versions of common fried foods you've had or the most interesting or uncommon but still standout fried dishes?2 pts
“Johnny's reef , city island for fried seafood”
H2
in:Shrimp, Soft Shell Crab, and Piña Coladas from Johnny’s Reef1 pts
“Their Henny coladas are really good too”
H2
in:Shrimp, Soft Shell Crab, and Piña Coladas from Johnny’s Reef1 pts
replying to u/nyknicks23: Their Henny coladas are really good too
“No trip to City Island complete without one.”
H2
in:Bronx hit list1 pts
“Johnnys reef, fried shrimp”
H2

See all 21 mentions