Buttercup Bake Shop — all mentions

in:Best Cupcake / Cakes?2 pts
“I like Buttercup Bake Shop. Especially the red velvet - one of the best ones I’ve had in my life. The right amount of moisture and frosting to cupcake ratio.”
H3
postBakeries where I can buy a whole loaf/pound cakes?8 pts
“An honorable mention of Buttercup Bake Shop, which has fantastic bundt cake by the slice”
H2
in:Any place to find Buttercream frosting cupcakes in manhattan?4 pts
replying to u/Motor_Pollution231: I think Buttercup Bake Shop does. They are between 51st and 52nd on 2nd Ave
“I really really like their cake slices. It was a once a year special treat when I worked in the area.”
H2
postLooking for chewy brownies 1 pts
“tried magnolias and buttercups but they were too dense and intense for me i don’t like my brownies too rich”
H2
in:Non-Magnolia Banana Pudding1 pts
“I had good luck with Buttercup Bake Shop’s version, much more pudding-y. Give them a go.”
H2
in:Red velvet1 pts
“Buttercup Bake Shop has a nice red velvet cake”
H2
in:Any place to find Buttercream frosting cupcakes in manhattan?1 pts
replying to u/Motor_Pollution231: I think Buttercup Bake Shop does. They are between 51st and 52nd on 2nd Ave
“Buttercup cupcakes are very sweet and cakelike, and their icing is more sugar than butter.”
H2
in:Any place to find Buttercream frosting cupcakes in manhattan?36 pts
“I think Buttercup Bake Shop does.”
H1
in:Birthday Cake in and/or delivered to Midtown East13 pts
“Would highly recommend buttercup bake shop!”
H1
in:Yellow Cake with Chocolate Frosting11 pts
“Buttercup Bake Shop”
H1
in:Any place to find Buttercream frosting cupcakes in manhattan?10 pts
“I love Buttercup Bake Shop”
H1
in:Best confetti or funfetti cake5 pts
“buttercup bake”
H1
in:Best Cupcake in NYC?4 pts
“In agreement that Buttercup Bake Shop is up there.”
H1
in:Birthday Cake in and/or delivered to Midtown East3 pts
“Buttercup Bake Shop and Magnolia are two other places to look at if you want more options to choose from.”
H1
in:Where can I find the most fudgy and dense cake?3 pts
“Like just to eat: Buttercup bake shop.”
H1
in:Birthday cake w/ 24 hr notice2 pts
“Buttercup bake shop!”
H1
in:Best chocolate cake in manhattan?2 pts
“Claude, buttercup bake shop, red gate bakery”
H1
in:Birthday Cake in and/or delivered to Midtown East2 pts
replying to u/pf1712: Would highly recommend buttercup bake shop! It’s on 2nd Ave between 51st and 52nd!
“I came to make this same recommendation.”
H1
in:Best “sweet treats?”1 pts
“I've tried buttercup, baked by melissa, and magnolia, and sprinkles is far superior!”
H1
in:Birthday cake slice (vanilla + sprinkles) in manhattan?1 pts
“Buttercup bakeshop was delicious when I had it”
H1
in:Is there anywhere in Manhattan where I can pickup a birthday cupcake?1 pts
“Their cup cakes are delicious and they might be able to do a festive theme for you.”
H1
in:Seeking snickerdoodle cookie anywhere in 5 boroughs1 pts
“Buttercup Bake Shop!! they have a couple locations in Manhattan”
H1
in:Best red velvet (with cream cheese frosting) dessert in the city?1 pts
“Buttercup bake shop!!!”
H1
in:Best Cupcake / Cakes?0 pts
replying to u/reddit-lurker-20: I like Buttercup Bake Shop. Especially the red velvet - one of the best ones I’ve had in my life. The right amount of moisture and frosting to cupcake ratio.
“This is the only right answer”
H1