Paneantico Bakery Cafe — all mentions

in:Looking for the best rainbow cookies. Where are your favorite rainbow cookies in the city and what have you compared them to so far?1 pts
replying to u/Shota_Kazehaya: Have you preferred them in comparison to any other places?
“Yes, I have tried quite a few and these are the best I’ve had. They are very moist, not excessively sweet and all the flavors and proportions are just right.”
H3
in:Best Eats in Bay Ridge?21 pts
“Paneantico makes excellent sandwiches.”
H2
in:what deli sandwich shop am I missing?10 pts
“Paneantico in Bay Ridge, get whatever your fav italian cold cut is with arugula and their balsamic glaze”
H2
in:Italian sandwich recommendations 3 pts
“The brick oven bread and balsamic with anything to top notch.”
H2
in:Favorite unique sandwiches in Brooklyn?2 pts
“Paneantico in Bay Ridge has what I consider the ultimate bacon egg and cheese on a brick oven roll or one of their really tasty bialis. I love their sausage egg and Swiss too. They're epic”
H2
in:Looking for the best Italian bread for sausage and peppers sandwich in Brooklyn2 pts
“Paneantico in Bay Ridge. Specifically their brick oven bread.”
H2
in:Day off today and craving a really good, relaxed sandwich for lunch9 pts
“Go to Bay Ridge. Paneantico. Make sure you use the blasamic.”
H1
in:Best Eats in Bay Ridge?7 pts
“Italian bakery: Paneantico or Tasty Pastry”
H1
in:Best Eats in Bay Ridge?3 pts
“Paneantico”
H1
in:Looking for the best rainbow cookies. Where are your favorite rainbow cookies in the city and what have you compared them to so far?3 pts
“imo it’s Royal Crown/Paneantico”
H1
in:Day off today and craving a really good, relaxed sandwich for lunch3 pts
replying to u/Deep-Emphasis-6785: Go to Bay Ridge. Paneantico. Make sure you use the blasamic. And go next door for a cupcake at little cup cake chop
“That was my routine for years!”
H1
in:Sfogliatella2 pts
replying to u/yiannistheman: That place outright sucks, political views notwithstanding. There's nothing they make that you can't find better elsewhere in Bay Ridge. The political stunt was just a desperate attempt to stay relevant because they weren't getting it done with food.
“I’d rather go to paneantico if I’m staying within a few blocks”
H1
in:Seeking best Caprese Sandwich in NYC2 pts
“Paneantico in Bay Ridge”
H1
in:Best Italian Heros?2 pts
“Paneantico in bay ridge”
H1
in:What’s your favorite sandwich shop and why is it Milano’s market on Broadway?2 pts
“Royal Crown or Paneantico for me.”
H1
in:Day off today and craving a really good, relaxed sandwich for lunch2 pts
replying to u/Teatime6023: That was my routine for years!
“Always a good move”
H1
in:Sfogliatella1 pts
“Best ones that I have tried are from Paneantico in BayRidge, Villabate on 18th Avenue and Delillo’s in the Bronx near Arthur Ave.”
H1
in:Favorite Blueberry Muffin?1 pts
“Paneantico, Bay Ridge, BK”
H1
in:Best Italian Heros?1 pts
replying to u/JayMoots: Your list is good. Defonte’s is the GOAT. Maybe add Fiore’s in Hoboken.
“awesome places”
H1
in:The best meal I’ve had in a long time: late lunch in Bay Ridge1 pts
“Paneantico. Great spot for lunch.”
H1
in:Hard bread Italian sandwich 😂1 pts
“I’m a Paneantico man myself”
H1
in:Where can I get the best mortadella sandwich?1 pts
“I really like Paneantico in Bay Ridge”
H1
in:Best Italian sandwich spot??1 pts
“Paneantico”
H1