Mariella Pizza

7.2/10Italian

AI-generated summary

Get the . One regular at the 70th and Lex shop was ordering the slice nearly every day. The gets named a lot, and a few people swear by the pie and the . Older regulars say the E 16th Street location was the best one and the others aren't quite the same.

965 Lexington Ave, New YorkUpper East Side, ManhattanGoogle Maps

What Reddit says14

View all

in:Chicken cutlet sandwich4 pts
“I love the chicken cutlet hero at Mariella Pizza”
H2
in:Where's the best grandma in the city?3 pts
“The Grandma slice at Mariella on 70th and Lex is incredible, I was getting it nearly every day at one point”
H2
in:Old school vs New School NYC pizza2 pts
replying to u/esbu: Mariella, Luigi's (the Ft. Greene one AND the famous one), Lunetta
“if their excellent pizza still exists, I'd be delighted to know more... :-)”
H2
in:Best chicken parm sub in NYC?1 pts
“The one at Mariella on the UES is fantastic”
H2
in:Favorite Pizza in NYC?1 pts
“Grandma Pizza @ Mariella”
H2
in:Two Week Trip Part 21 pts
replying to u/fillb3rt: Bruh that pizza looks saaaaddddd. Is that really Joes??
“Base was actually good, but the toppings were definitely the weakest of slices we had.”
H2
in:Any closed restaurants that you miss?1 pts
replying to u/DFVSUPERFAN: MY MAN! Didn't see this post but had the same thought. So mad.
“But the upper midtown Mariella was good, but not the same as E 16th St. Do you remember that sweet tinge in the sauce? Their lasagna was also deadly good.”
H2
in:Any closed restaurants that you miss?1 pts
replying to u/Quantumercifier: Mariella Pizza, but specifically the one on E 16th St and 3rd Ave. They had a distinctive sauce that was slightly sweet. The other Mariella's were also good, but not exactly the same as the E 16th location.
“Their chicken parm pie was the best I’ve ever had. No one makes it as good no matter where I go.”
H2

See all 14 mentions