“Was it absolutely perfect when I would stop in for a $2 slice on my way home at like 11 pm? 100%.”
H2
All 24 rated mentions, most helpful first
“Was it absolutely perfect when I would stop in for a $2 slice on my way home at like 11 pm? 100%.”
H2
“For pizza I prefer Freddie and Peppers over the others in the area.”
H2
“I personally wouldn't make a special trip for it, even though it's a very good slice (usually).”
H2
“Agree, 4/10 at best. Serviceable slice but certainly wouldn’t point someone there”
H2
“No that place is way too greasy and doughy”
H2
“Freddie and pepper’s meat lover’s slice”
H2
“Also the whole wheat spinich white pizza”
H2
“Freddie and peppers on uws is a great slice shop that gets no love.”
H2
“Too thick and heavy imo. Almost a pan pizza in weight”
H2
“Solid 4/10. Desperately needed salt and the dough tasted chemically”
H1
“Freddie and Peppers sucks.”
H1
“The only answer is Freddie and Pepper's on Amsterdam and 74th.”
H1
“Sal & carmine’s, Freddie & pepper’s, Mimi’s, cheesy pizza.”
H1
“Freddie & Peppers (a little gimmicky and more about toppings )”
H1
“Freddie & Peppers. Bonus points it’s actually in NYC”
H1
“I second Freddie and Pepper if you’re just looking for a quick slice near the beacon”
H1
“Great slice places are all over the city. Shout out to some of the places near where I’ve lived over the years: - Freddie & Peppers: Amsterdam & 74th”
H1
“Freddie and peppers is legit BAD. Like in a race to the bottom with the Rays by the museum for worst in the UWS”
H1
“No Freddie &peppers on this list”
H1
“Freddie and Pepper's UWS. Amsterdam and 74th”
H1
“On the way to the airport, I got Freddie's and was awesome to for a slice.”
H1
“Freddie peppers upper west side as well is Underated.”
H1
“So good”
H1
“Freddie & peppers for some real stuff”
H1