Cappone's

6.7/10

AI-generated summary

Sandwiches run about $20 and people say they're worth it. The is the one to get, and a few argue it beats Faicco's. The gets less love, and one person found the semolina bread too soft and chewy.

11 Abingdon Square, New YorkWest Village, ManhattanGoogle Maps

What Reddit says20

View all

in:Pastrami chopped cheese from Edith’s sandwich counter3 pts
replying to u/marketingguy420: Haven't tried this one, but I got a few other sandwiches there that were... fine. But it feels bad paying $20 for a sandwich that isn't amazing.
“Every sandwich I've had there is worth the $20ish ive paid.”
H2
in:If I’m a Portlander who has fallen in love with Italian sandwiches, visiting Manhattan, anywhere Harlem and below, and I want a legit NY Italian Sub (quality cured meats, quality formaggio, fresh baked bread) where am I going to get the real deal? 2 pts
replying to u/skimcpip: Cappone’s
“I was disappointed with the semolina bread. Too soft and chewy”
H2
in:Anyone have any Chicken cutlet sandwich recs? Have been to Faicco’s for Italian2 pts
“Cappones is superior chicken parm to Faiccos”
H2
in:Recs needed for incoming Parsons freshman (Philly native)2 pts
“cappones (better than Faiccos imo)”
H2
in:What's the best thing you've eaten in the past week?1 pts
“The Cappone sandwich from Cappone’s”
H2
in:Where can I get the best mortadella sandwich?1 pts
“BRO. Have the Gabriella at Cappone's in the West Village. This place hasn't been influencered yet thank god (though not sure why - it way outclasses lots of places people wait on line for lol).”
H2
in:Pastrami chopped cheese from Edith’s sandwich counter1 pts
replying to u/FitzwilliamTDarcy: Hit Cappone's. Every sandwich I've had there is worth the $20ish ive paid.
“I got the meatball sandwich and... also fine lol. Like certainly better than a deli meatball sub, but I didn't think it was on Feicos' level.”
H2
in:Help me find the Chicken Parm Hero of my dreams1 pts
“Cappones Vodka Sauce Chicken Parm in the West Village🤤😋”
H2

See all 20 mentions