Ortobello's

All 25 rated mentions, most helpful first

in:Aside from L&B, what's good in this area of Brooklyn? Boundaries: south of Bay Parkway, Kings Highway, and Flatbush Ave.4 pts
replying to u/mariskaleh: Liman (Turkish seafood) Taci's Beyti (Turkish) Brennan & Carr (roast beef) Mill Basin Deli (Kosher deli)
“Ortobellos (big portions, old school vibes)”
H2
in:Your Favorite Clam Dishes in Manhattan or Brooklyn!4 pts
“Baked clams at Ortobellos in Bensonhurst”
H2
in:NYC's Best Chicken Parm?3 pts
replying to u/Macredd: Ortobellos in Brooklyn
“The Mozzarella Carozza there is ridiculous”
H2
in:Red Sauce Italian3 pts
“Ortobello's is a trip but there's nothing like it. Andy is wonderful he is very social and fun to talk to. It's a hole in the wall but it's an institution from the 70s.”
H2
in:Favorite vodka sauce dish2 pts
“They have a spicy vodka sauce chicken parm that was unbelievable when I went there last month.”
H2
in:Red Sauce Italian1 pts
“this place is exactly what you described. kinda small, mom & dad do the cooking. their kids are the servers. classic red sauce place.”
H2
in:Best chicken parm in NY?8 pts
“Ortobellos and Tony's Di Napoli are my top 2 so far.”
H1
in:Best unpretentious, classic Italians (pasta or pizza)7 pts
“I can recommend three off the top of my head… Ortobello’s, Joe’s of Avenue U (Sicilian), and Randazzo’s Clam Bar (specifically for seafood)”
H1
in:NYC's Best Chicken Parm?5 pts
“Ortobellos in Brooklyn”
H1
in:best "hole in the wall" you’ve found lately?4 pts
“Ortobello's checks all your boxes.”
H1
in:NYC's Best Chicken Parm?3 pts
replying to u/phishyphriend: Driven by this place a million times going to my MIL's house but had never considered stopping in, now I'm intrigued. Thanks for tip!
“Family run classic Italian that has been there forever. It’s a neighborhood staple and everything is authentic and delicious.”
H1
in:NYC's Best Chicken Parm?3 pts
replying to u/Macredd: Ortobellos in Brooklyn
“Best in NYC”
H1
in:Best chicken parm in NY?3 pts
replying to u/Macredd: Ortobellos and Tony's Di Napoli are my top 2 so far.
“Ortbello’s - this guy knows ball”
H1
in:Linguine and Clams - White Sauce3 pts
“Ortobello’s, Randazzo’s Clam Bar”
H1
in:Italian Restaurants overlooked by Eater NY2 pts
“you left out ortobellos when mentioning old school places in Brooklyn.”
H1
in:Brooklyn Restaurants for Out of Towners!2 pts
“Places I like that aren’t TOOOO far from the park slope area: Hometown bbq Red hook tavern Brooklyn roots Brooklyn farmacy for ice cream Fonda Tacos el bronco (the truck if time is short) Al di la The commissioner (dive bar) Vinnys of Carroll gardens Frankie’s 457 Ortobellos”
H1
in:NYC's Best Chicken Parm?2 pts
replying to u/Macredd: Ortobellos in Brooklyn
“My friend in Bay Ridge swears by Ortobellos”
H1
in:red sauce Italian2 pts
“Ortobello's, Bay Parkway, Brooklyn”
H1
in:Where’s your favorite Tiramisu spot? Preferably in Brooklyn but open to all recommendations.1 pts
“Ortobellos bay ridge you will never get better”
H1
in:What are some NYC restaurants that are criminally underrated?1 pts
“Simple, yet incredible dishes and warm hospitality.”
H1
in:What’s one underrated NYC restaurant you always take out-of-towners to (that’s not super touristy)?1 pts
“Ortobello's”
H1
in:Italian restaurant (not pizzeria) in South Brooklyn or Park Slope area w/ great chicken parm?1 pts
“Ortobellos is the only correct answer”
H1
in:red sauce Italian1 pts
“Ortobellos, La Palina, Vinny’s of Carroll Gardens, Gargiulo’s.”
H1
in:NYC's Best Chicken Parm?1 pts
“Ortobello’s in Brooklyn”
H1
in:Best chicken parmesean in NYC recommendation??????1 pts
“Located in Brooklyn in a small Resturant. Ortobello's”
H1