Jeni's — all mentions

in:Salted Butter Ice Cream?3 pts
“I was shocked how butter flavored Jeni’s brown butter almond ripple was. Too much so for me personally, but if that is what you’re looking for.”
H3
in:I love Caffe Panna ice cream, but it’s a frustrating business4 pts
“a pint of Jeni’s from Wholefoods is way better”
H2
in:Mint chip aficionados, (I know, I know), what are your favorite places for mint chip that have really crunchy and well-tempered chips?3 pts
“to me this is the perfect mint chip. They use tons of huge dark bitter chocolate chips and the texture of the cream is amazing.”
H2
in:Best dishes with goat cheese in the city?2 pts
“Jeni’s makes an incredible goat cheese & red cherry ice cream.”
H2
in:Best mint choc chip ice cream?2 pts
“Jeni’s Savannah Buttermint will blow your mind. Not the same as a local cone I know but OMG. It’s amazing.”
H2
in:Does anyone else remember Steve's ice cream? Have you had any ice cream elsewhere that has come close to tasting like their Brooklyn Blackout flavor?2 pts
“Jeni’s Blackout Chocolate Cake is pretty good!”
H2
in:How is caffe panna so good?1 pts
replying to u/Mysterious-Sir-5837: So funny you say this. I've lived in NYC for 4 years and have never tried it. Love ice cream. I decided to go today. I got the Oreo PB fluff - so up my alley. It had almost 0 mix-in. I had to grab extra PB from my pantry because there was not close to enough in the ice cream. Barely any Oreo. It was good (because all ice cream is good in my opinion - no way to screw it up unless you REALLY screw it up) but not even close to the best ice cream I've ever had. So disappointing for what I was expecting (again, not bad). I would take Jeni's and even the PB honeycomb from Van Leeuwen over it (most similar flavor comparison). I would take B&J's over it. Maybe I just got a bad batch or something. Also, I judge ice cream much more on flavors/mix-ins and almost barely on quality so that may be it as I know CP is known for quality. I don't really care about the "quality" of the ice cream as long as the final product as good. I really wanted to love it and will have to try again but won't go out of my way necessarily.
“I would take a Jeni’s pint over Cafe Panna any day.”
H2
in:Which ice cream places have the best, top tier vanilla that would turn a skeptic into a believer?1 pts
“Jeni's Vanilla is great”
H2
in:How is caffe panna so good?11 pts
“I would take Jeni's and even the PB honeycomb from Van Leeuwen over it”
H1
in:I love Caffe Panna ice cream, but it’s a frustrating business3 pts
replying to u/elenafoxx: What bothers me the most is the standing around and doing nothing people… my other favorite is Morgenstern the main location closed but the Bananas place on Rivington is still selling pints and they have intriguing flavors and top notch quality.. I love quirky flavors like Salt & Straw but don’t find the ice cream quality to be very good… agree that Van Leeuwens is awful- it’s ok as a grocery store ice cream to get something organic / no fillers but there’s very little inclusion of the actual flavor and just not very good and certainly not worth waiting for… a pint of Jeni’s from Wholefoods is way better.. 🍨
“team Jeni’s!”
H1
in:Post-trip food ratings2 pts
replying to u/ContextFew721: Panna is the best ice cream I’ve ever had in my life
“the only ones that really come close for me are Jeni's and McConnell's.”
H1
in:Blue Moon Ice Cream?!?1 pts
replying to u/Final-Elderberry9162: Jeni’s ice cream had a blue moon flavor that I could find in NYC but they don’t always have it.
“Jeni does not miss”
H1