El Mitote

6.7/10Mexican

AI-generated summary

El Mitote is the casual Mexican spot the Upper West Side names first. People go for the guacamole, the quesadillas and the frozen margaritas, especially the blood orange one. The come with goat milk dulce de leche. Not everyone is sold, and a few say it's overpriced or just not good Mexican.

208 Columbus Ave, New YorkUpper West Side, ManhattanGoogle Maps

What Reddit says29

View all
  • I think El Mitote's is very good, especially with the goat milk dulche de leche it comes with.

    H2

  • replying to u/myspicename: I think El Mitote's is very good, especially with the goat milk dulche de leche it comes with.

    Their frozen margaritas were good, too - the blood orange in particular! It was almost creamy.

    H2

  • El Mitote (amazing guacamole and good all-around though doesn't have quite as memorable tortillas as downtown, both as much better than typical burrito fare.

    H2