Brooklyn Crab

All 27 rated mentions, most helpful first

post4 days eating through NYC136 pts
“I thought the fish and chips and lobster roll were solid here, nothing crazy.”
H2
in:Best Fried Shrimp in NYC?4 pts
“Brooklyn Crab has some great fried shrimp”
H2
in:Balthazar Seafood Tower 11/303 pts
“I had great seafood towers at Seawolf and Brooklyn Crab.”
H2
in:Great view of city or Brooklyn Bridge that is not $50+ dollars a plate or super fancy?1 pts
replying to u/elborzo: The worst place
“I had mac&cheese + other sides and enjoyed it.”
H2
in:Favorite Crab Dish in NYC?1 pts
replying to u/FrequentSwan1046: Brooklyn crab in red hook
“Came here to say this! Also, AYCE crab legs in summer!”
H2
in:4 days eating through NYC1 pts
“I think most of their food is pretty overpriced for the quality.”
H2
in:I want to show my friend distinctly American foods in NYC. Where should I bring them?70 pts
“Redhook - has hometown bbq, brooklyn crab, redhook tavern, red hook lobster pound”
H1
in:My friends and I need recs for a Brooklyn food tour9 pts
“Hometown BBQ, Brooklyn Crab, Sunny’s, Strong rope, Steve’s key lime pie makes for a perfect day.”
H1
in:Best restaurants on the water? 5 pts
“Brooklyn Crab. Sit upstairs.”
H1
in:4 days eating through NYC5 pts
“brooklyn crab is fun”
H1
in:I am having a huge craving for fried calamari. What are some standout places to get it, like either personal favorites, cheap but somehow still good quality, more-massive-than-average portion sizes, or ones that are served different than with the typical tomato sauce or aioli?3 pts
“Brooklyn crab does a great job of it.”
H1
in:Favorite Crab Dish in NYC?3 pts
“Brooklyn crab in red hook”
H1
in:Recommendations for good quality but casual sea food restaurants?2 pts
“Brooklyn crab but more in summer obviously”
H1
in:Great view of city or Brooklyn Bridge that is not $50+ dollars a plate or super fancy?2 pts
replying to u/m1kasa4ckerman: Brooklyn Crab in red hook? Pretty cool open views of the water.
“The worst place”
H1
in:Best outdoor spot for four 40 year old guys for dinner? Brooklyn, Queens, Manhattan only.2 pts
replying to u/Sufficient_Flight_44: Hometown BBQ in Red Hook
“Or next door at Brooklyn crab”
H1
in:Summer Food Bucket List2 pts
“Take the ferry to Red Hook and hit Brooklyn Crab.”
H1
in:Snow/King crab recs2 pts
“Brooklyn crab!”
H1
in:Who has the best crab dishes in NYC1 pts
“Brooklyn Crab in Red Hook is excellent, but waaaaaay expensive! If cost isn't an issue, it's a good option.”
H1
in:What is your favorite seafood restaurant in the City? (separate by cheap and expensive)1 pts
“$$$: Brooklyn Crab in Red Hook, Greenpoint Fish & Lobster”
H1
in:Waterfront views 1 pts
“Westlight, Rivercafe and Brooklyn Crab”
H1
in:Looking for a specific vibe1 pts
“Brooklyn Crab in Red Hook. The perfect late summer destination.”
H1
in:Breakfast/ Lunch in Red Hook?1 pts
“Brooklyn Crab or Hometown BBQ and then stop by Sunny's!”
H1
in:Best seafood restaurant with a nice ambience1 pts
“Brooklyn Crab”
H1
in:Looking to impress my tattooed, millennial sister visiting from Portland, ME. Williamsburg/Greenpoint … something uniquely of the area. Price/genre not important, just vibe. I’m older and out of touch.1 pts
replying to u/Other-Aside-1170: Favourite spot, but it's generally super crowded
“If it's nice bk crab around the corner is good for a sunset.”
H1
in:Looking for unique dessert spots in NYC with interesting flavors1 pts
replying to u/nico__nico: Not in Queens, but Steve's Key Lime Pie is a great excuse to explore Red Hook! I like riding my bike there and sitting in the park with my individual-sized pie. They also have frozen ones with a chocolate shell, great on a hot day.
“There’s a wonderful Crab spot with a rooftop that overlooks the water…”
H1
in:Any suggestions for a Manhattan seafood lunch coming in at under three figures?1 pts
“Take ferry to red hook and go to redhook lobster pound or Brooklyn crab”
H1
in:Balthazar Seafood Tower 11/303 pts
“Same with Brooklyn Crab in Red Hook but that place is opened only for the season.”
H0